Favorite Pizza in SoWal

[SWGB]

Go for it, you've only got 14 days...

[Allifunn]

I have not had pizza at every establishment listed, but I do have it on expert authority that Fat C's is the best...considering the individual ate their weight in pizza while in Italy and says Fat C's is the closest to authentic pizza.

[kurt]

Thanks for the poll! I want pizza right now for breakfast. mmmmmmmmmmmmmm

Mind if we change it to 14 days?

[Smiling JOe]

Carabba's has pizza? Who knew. I've never been to Carabba's. I've never been to Fat Clemenza's either, but since it is west of the Factory Stores (outlet mall), I consider that out of my driving range for lunch in SoWal. However, I may have to give it a whirl soon.

I've seen the pizza at Sugar Pies. I cannot believe it is on this list. lol. I see that the owner of Bruno's already voted. lol.

[billharr]

I don't care what this poll says...Enzo's comes the closest to a NY pizza...All the others are very good but Enzo's is the best!!

[KSVAJ]

Not only is it the best pizza in SoWal, it's the BEST pizza you'll ever eat! Crispy yet chewy crust, savory sauces and cheeses, and the freshest toppings around. I love kalamata olives, fresh garlic, and basil on my pie. I was never really a pizza fan until I ate at PBTS....my husband, on the other hand, has a "pizza addiction" & is a connoisseur....he'll only eat PBTS pizza! Oh, and BTW, their salads rock too!

[Romeosmydog]

Brody asks us every night if we can eat at "Pitza in the C"

We love PBTS and try to eat there at least 2 nights a week.

[thisnthat]

The atmosphere at Pizza by the Sea is hard to beat even if you don't care for the pizza. Very family friendly.

[babyshoes]

Pizza by the Sea is the best! You can take the kids and everyone has fun. Great pizza!

[Teresa]

Fat Clemenza's is my favorite restaurant on the planet. But, I voted on Pizza by the Sea for the best pizza. I think they have created an entirely unique pizza pie that is scrumptious! and enjoyed by all. the atmosphere is also wonderful.

I do love Enzo's pizza as well. and Fat Clemenza's guys throw a real authentic Italian style pizza - the guys are literally from Italy, and they are cooking in a wood fired oven. It is one of those places that we are so blessed to have nearby.

But as far as best all around within SoWal, my vote goes to Pizza by the Sea... that place is uniquely fun and yummy.

[Beach Bimmer]

The Fired Up Fun Crew votes Pizza By The Sea!

[ImissSoWal]

I live in New York now but, Enzo's was and is still my favorite place to eat. I LOVE Enzo's pizza. In fact when I lived in SoWal i always looked for a pizza that compaired to the "New York" syle pizza. Now that I am in NY again I find my self looking for the "ENZO's" style pizza. NY can not even compair it seems.

[JUL]

I will have to try pizza by the sea

[pizdets]

Having tried most of the options, I've got to go with Pizza By the Sea hands down. Amore was good and will be missed, but if I don't have my Pizza By the Sea at least once a week I have withdrawls.

[Teresa]

I live in New York now but, Enzo's was and is still my favorite place to eat. I LOVE Enzo's pizza. In fact when I lived in SoWal i always looked for a pizza that compaired to the "New York" syle pizza. Now that I am in NY again I find my self looking for the "ENZO's" style pizza. NY can not even compair it seems.

Enzo pizza is outstanding. have you tried Fat Clemenza's??? we're fortunate to have several kinds of pizzas around here. and we have more pizza coming to Seaside soon - can't wait!!! I do love: Pizza by the Sea, Enzo's, and Fat Clemenza's... and what is that place in Silver Sands owned by Guglielmo's that has great pizza?

we're very pizza blessed around here!!!

and what's going on with Amore'?

[JUL]

Which one of these places serves pizza and beer?

[SWGB]

Thanks for the poll! I want pizza right now for breakfast. mmmmmmmmmmmmmm

Mind if we change it to 14 days?

Definitely. Please note that you are not limited to one choice, I thought that wouldn't be fair.

Carabba's has pizza? Who knew. I've never been to Carabba's. I've never been to Fat Clemenza's either, but since it is west of the Factory Stores (outlet mall), I consider that out of my driving range for lunch in SoWal. However, I may have to give it a whirl soon.

I've seen the pizza at Sugar Pies. I cannot believe it is on this list. lol. I see that the owner of Bruno's already voted. lol.

Carabba's does have pizza, but they aren't open for lunch. It is actually cooked in a wood fired oven.

I tried to include everyone that served pizza. Of course I ran out at 10 choices max so I didn't include Pizza Hut .

Having tried most of the options, I've got to go with Pizza By the Sea hands down. Amore was good and will be missed, but if I don't have my Pizza By the Sea at least once a week I have withdrawls.

My understanding is that Amore is still open unless this has somehow changed.

Which one of these places serves pizza and beer?

All of them except Bruno's.

[pizdets]

I'm not sure exactly what's up with Amore. Have been by 3 times lately for lunch and they were closed. But they are still advertising lunch and dinner in the Sun and there's a sign up saying they now deliver. So I guess I spoke prematurely. I guess I'll have to stick with old faithful PBtS until I know what's what

[Smiling JOe]

I don't care what this poll says...Enzo's comes the closest to a NY pizza...All the others are very good but Enzo's is the best!!

This poll doesn't mention "NY" style pizza.

[Minnie]

Pizza by the Sea is very good. Yall are very lucky to have so many good local choices for Pizza. In Memphis we are very limited to anything other than franchise pizza places.

[kurt]

Added to SoWal.com home page.

[Allifunn]

Pizza By the Sea is the best in the SoWal area...for convenience, friendliness, tastiness and atmosphere!!!
Going outside the 30-A to 30-A area...Fat Clemenza's is wonderful. But I do need to give Enzos and Brunos a chance. Amore's was always my favorite...but I have not been there in a while...I miss Olive

[rdelong43065]

Pizza By the Sea is the best in the SoWal area...for convenience, friendliness, tastiness and atmosphere!!!
Going outside the 30-A to 30-A area...Fat Clemenza's is wonderful. But I do need to give Enzos and Brunos a chance. Amore's was always my favorite...but I have not been there in a while...I miss Olive

Bruno's always seems to get a bad rap and I don't know why. He does a phenomenal business there. I do like the grilled chicken pizza there.

[cooper]

Bruno's (and just one day at the beach) worth the 8 and a half hour drive down

[AliKat]

I have never been a big pizza eater, but once I found Pizza by the Sea I fell in love. Best pizza I have ever had by far!!!

[Babyblue]

My family and I eat at pizza by the sea at least once a week. The kids go crazy without it! Next time you call ask about the Colby Special!! ;)

[NightAngel]

I have 3 teenagers so for the size and price, I am going with Fat Daddy's. When you order a large there you get a super huge pizza at a fair price and the kids love it. I am not a pizza eater but I love the cheese bread but brunos is my favorite cheese bread, no sauce, lots of feta...yum.

[DeaconRhonda]

Pizza by the Sea is incredible! I could just eat the crunchy, chewy crust for every meal. My husband and I love pizza and we try it almost everywhere we go - or at least we use to. But not anymore, because we are always greatly disappointed. No pizza we have ever had even comes close to being as good as PBTS's Queen Margherita! Thanks to the Crusty Crew of PBTS!!!!

[olive]

Pizza By the Sea is the best in the SoWal area...for convenience, friendliness, tastiness and atmosphere!!!
Going outside the 30-A to 30-A area...Fat Clemenza's is wonderful. But I do need to give Enzos and Brunos a chance. Amore's was always my favorite...but I have not been there in a while...I miss Olive

I miss you, too!

[bigskybeachmom]

Hands down - PIZZA BY THE SEA! The best pizza ever.

[JUL]

Who gives the best deals when you have to feed a crowd and who delivers to Watercolor

[CJ]

I LOVE Pizza by the Sea's buffalo chicken Pizza and because we are sometimes vegetarians, it is even good without chicken!

Also love to let the little one create her own. She is 3 and lately it has been pineapple, pepperoni, and black olive. YUMMY?

Oh and they have really good sandwiches too...I mean really good

[edmondson_s]

Pizza by the Sea is the absolute best! That has become our traditional first night meal when we arrive. It's addictive!!! I hope they do not develop a 12 step program for this place! Two thumbs w-a-a-a-y up!

[cheesehead]

Pizza by the Sea. At least for the area. Miss the pizza back in cheeseland alot. Otherwise. I make my own.

[cynthia.mulit]

We had a great pizza night. I think the reason Enzp's isn't the top rated is that we are all too stuffed and happy to log on!

[Miss Kitty]

I still say the Pizza By The Sea crust was chewier last Spring.

[NightAngel]

Who gives the best deals when you have to feed a crowd and who delivers to Watercolor

I have a large family so we are always feeding a crowd and Fat Daddys is the best deal to feed a crowd and I believe they do deliver to watercolor. You can check their website www.fatdaddyspizza.com

[poppy]

Pizza by the Sea is very good. Yall are very lucky to have so many good local choices for Pizza. In Memphis we are very limited to anything other than franchise pizza places.

Try Little Italy, Coletta's, or Old Venice.

[Teresa]

I LOVE Pizza by the Sea's buffalo chicken Pizza and because we are sometimes vegetarians, it is even good without chicken!

Also love to let the little one create her own. She is 3 and lately it has been pineapple, pepperoni, and black olive. YUMMY?

Oh and they have really good sandwiches too...I mean really good

wail hail! look who it is!!! the creator of the best sowal thread EVER... that's who! P-cake anyone?

[a30aspice]

The only consistently excellent pizza I've had in South Walton didn't even make your polling list.....JORDANO'S

[SWGB]

The only consistently excellent pizza I've had in South Walton didn't even make your polling list.....JORDANO'S

Big Whoops there, I do love Jordano's. My sincere apologies.

[sunspotbaby]

short story

dined in at PBTS before poll started:
enjoyable pizza, good sauce, but thought it was lacking in 2 of the 3 toppings, very crisp crust throughout. Funn atmosphere, kid-friendly.

Carry out pizza from Enzos after poll started:
Giant box! Toppings were plentiful,
good sauce,crust under pizza was cooked but floppy, perfectly browned outter crust. Looked a little fancy inside for 2 kids but that's why it was carry out.

Hubby is from Jersey, he preferred Enzos.


Two different atmospheres.
two different pizza styles.
Love 'em both!

[kurt]

Last Chance to vote today!!!

[You Rang?]

I'm goin' with Bruno's
Jeff's a great guy with a great pie and it's 2 for 1 !
Garlic knots are the best too

[Hypnautiq]

What about Cabana Cafe, can watch them toss your pizza in a show kitchen. Specialty pizzas like greek, cajun, and cordon bleu...bar open till 2am serving food 7am-2am. a lot of these chains are fine but why not try some1 from your neighborhood doing pizza the right way. cabanacafedestin.com

[SWGB]

What about Cabana Cafe, can watch them toss your pizza in a show kitchen. Specialty pizzas like greek, cajun, and cordon bleu...bar open till 2am serving food 7am-2am. a lot of these chains are fine but why not try some1 from your neighborhood doing pizza the right way. cabanacafedestin.com

The only chain listed is Carabba's. The rest are locally owned and operated.

[kurt]

Thanks to everyone who voted and congrats to Pizza By The Sea!

Try them out y'all - Voted SoWal.com Favorite

[Allifunn]

Thanks to everyone who voted and congrats to Pizza By The Sea!

Try them out y'all - Voted SoWal.com Favorite

Quite an honor!

[Smiling JOe]

congratulations, Pizza by the Sea!

[lumgod]

Amore is the best pizza around! MMMMMMMM!!!!!!