Mine went up!!! I'm calling tomorrow. I am with citizens. Mine is $3088 this year and I have a 108 year old 2 bedroom, 1 bath house! I'm gettin' robbed!
You might be getting hit harder due to the home being so old. I assume it isn't built with hurricane resistant windows/doors, rebar in the walls tying the roof to the concrete in the ground, etc. The discounts are fairly high for homes built to code over the last 5 years or so.