What would use for bait in the surf?
I was trying to dodge that question because the answer is "it depends". This is one of those questions that, if posed to five different fishermen, may yield 18 different answers.
Regarding natural baits, lately we've had people swear that ONLY cigar minnows work. Whole, not cut. Others swear that ONLY live shrimp, frozen shrimp, squid, live sand fleas, live minnows, Gulp! sand fleas, and the list goes on. Some use only artificial lures with good success. The point is, there is no universal right or wrong answer. It will depend on the current conditions, like temperature, water clarity, season, surf height, presence of baitfish, etc.
Conditions change constantly around here and what works one day may not work the next. That is both the fun and, for some, the frustration of surf fishing.
Stop by our Seagrove store for the latest info.