I didn't know there were two, but I went to the one on 30A just east of 393 with the seafood market, on sept 18th. It was my first visit.
The food was good !!! The fish was almost equal to Stinky's, but the service was very poor. When I asked to talk with the manager, both my server and the bartender told me the manager was not available. I will surely go back for a second chance but I don't think the others I was with will. I am not trying to drag down goatfeathers, just sharing my experience.
Hope you all had good dining experiences there.
TT