St. Joe will sell for what the market will bear. If a buyer is paying cash, so be it. If financed, appraislas are required, which reflect comparable sales. Do you think taht someone paying $1.5 million for a house a mile from the beach is counting on rentals to pay their mortgage?
Classic and timeless beach homes, while prices may seem outrageous to many of us, are much more than numbers on the sheet for those that will end up owning them for many years. And many of them will end up being owned by people who will value them for generations, with wonderful memories that are difficult to put a dollar value on.
There are a lot of folks here that are out of my league, and many more I've yet to see.
Such has been the case with Ono Island, Star Island, Marco Island, Sea Island, Malibu, Hilton Head, The Hamptons, Seaside, Rosemary Beach, and is soon to be the case at WaterColor, WaterSound, Alys Beach, etc . . .
They come, they stay, they buy. They care little whether a couple of folks have flipped their beach home. They care little what the developer or builder made. They want their beach home.
If you are simplifying the real estate market here all the way to the point of comparing it to the stock market, then you just don't get it.
What is your real issue? You lost money in stocks and now you want to watch others suffer?