Maybe this is all very subjective. I've only been to Dewey's twice in the last year. First time was OK. Second time was rather bland. I actually liked Bayou Bill's for that kind of seafood. When Nick's came back to the beach a couple years ago, it was disappointing, so I haven't given it a second chance. Because of the expense of going out to dinner around here, I always tend to go to the consistently good places and take no chances.