Well I am no closer to deciding and now RO has thrown in another very viable option. My kids would love that pool and the playground. Thank you all for your input thus far!
Beachmom - we will have to arrange a visit regardless of where we stay! I will be there the end of April by myself, staying with Audie and her husband, and then back in August with my kids. Last year the kids and I stayed at Cottages of Camp Creek and loved it, but I thought we'd venture a little further west this trip (unless, of course, RO makes me an offer I can't refuse - LOL!!)
Linda, I just think I might be back in August too! It just this second clicked with me.....I'm still a little fuzzy from the cosmos and the shredding!