Back to All About SoWal

Superintendent of Schools - political race

Smiling JOe avatar
Smiling JOeSoWal Expert
8,598 views
Carlene H Anderson
vs
Trisha Porter Hutchinson


I've read through Trisha Porter Hutchinson's thread, and haven't seen anything on Carlene Anderson. Does anyone have any comments regarding Carlene running for Superintendent of Schools? :idontno:

Replies

46
Jdarg avatar
JdargSoWal Expert
#2
The choice is easy in the Superintendent's race. The choice is easy for me. Carlene Anderson.

The school board is used to working with her, and we will only have 1 new school board member (as I imagine Mark Davis will and should be re-elected), and if Robert Nelson wins the other board position, then he has been to so many school board meetings and has been uber-involved with the school system over the years to jump right in and work with her. I guess what I am trying to say that I would see the start of the year as fairly seamless on both sides if Carlene gets re-elected- no down time for a learning curve.

I have only heard teachers speak well of her south of the bay, our test scores went up, we have some schools making great improvements, and overall our district seems to be improving - so why rock the boat? I say give her more years to show us what she can do. A change here would just slow up progress at this point, IMO. There is no good reason to replace her at this time.

Edited

bentley williams avatar
bentley williamsBeach Fanatic
#3
I trust Jdarg. She is one of the most involved and knowledgeable school parents in SoWal.

Still, I would like to see Carlene Anderson on this forum. This is one of the best ways to connect with voters and school parents. Someone who knows her should send her a link. Jdarg?
5th Gen LocalBeach Comber
#4
Vote Anderson

This one is not complicated at all for those of use who have lived here since day one. Carlene is a lifelong educator and her record speaks for her.

Mrs. Porter got mad at the way her son was handled after he participated in vandalism of school property, so she ran as an act of vengence.

Don't waste anymore of your time on this one, you can move on to the other races for research.
bentley williams avatar
bentley williamsBeach Fanatic
#5
Thanks 5thGen - I hope to see more input from you as a longtime local I bet you have the skinny.
5th Gen LocalBeach Comber
#6
Thanks 5thGen - I hope to see more input from you as a longtime local I bet you have the skinny.
I do... and you will see more from me. I have been a silent observer for a long time, but have found you all to be very intelligent and interested in change. For too long I have watched these folks attempt to deceive you guys on the threads.

I also want to tell you who the good guys in county government as we continue discussions. Don't want to flood the air waves in one night.
ckhagen avatar
ckhagenBeach Fanatic
#7
I have no idea what exactly the "issues" are because I don't have kids in school, but I will say that I've heard from multiple, unrelated people about fear of retribution for opposing Ms. Anderson on nearly anything. The first time I heard it I blew it off as one persons problem, but now that I've heard it on several occasions from people who don't run in the same circles, I have to consider that there's some truth to it. Not saying that the opposition is "better" (again, I don't know the issues here), but you have to wonder when there's this much tension about one person.
Jdarg avatar
JdargSoWal Expert
#8
I have no idea what exactly the "issues" are because I don't have kids in school, but I will say that I've heard from multiple, unrelated people about fear of retribution for opposing Ms. Anderson on nearly anything. The first time I heard it I blew it off as one persons problem, but now that I've heard it on several occasions from people who don't run in the same circles, I have to consider that there's some truth to it. Not saying that the opposition is "better" (again, I don't know the issues here), but you have to wonder when there's this much tension about one person.

I think it would be unrealistic to expect every single WCSG employee to be happy. There are too many employees for every single one to be have a perfect experience- that is not real life. And we usually only hear the bad stories, not the good.

I bet there is not a school system in the country that has a superintendent that every single parent and employee agrees with 100% of the time.
seagrovegirl avatar
seagrovegirlBeach Fanatic
#9
I have no idea what exactly the "issues" are because I don't have kids in school, but I will say that I've heard from multiple, unrelated people about fear of retribution for opposing Ms. Anderson on nearly anything. The first time I heard it I blew it off as one persons problem, but now that I've heard it on several occasions from people who don't run in the same circles, I have to consider that there's some truth to it. Not saying that the opposition is "better" (again, I don't know the issues here), but you have to wonder when there's this much tension about one person.

Can you give a hypothetical scenario of who the multiple people are, parents, teachers or staff and what kind of retribution? This is a serious charge.
sowalwalBeach Crab
#10
Can you give a hypothetical scenario of who the multiple people are, parents, teachers or staff and what kind of retribution? This is a serious charge.

Fear or retribution? The only people that should be fearful are those who are not doing their job, shoe doens't put up with that!
sowalwalBeach Crab
#11
I trust Jdarg. She is one of the most involved and knowledgeable school parents in SoWal.

Still, I would like to see Carlene Anderson on this forum. This is one of the best ways to connect with voters and school parents. Someone who knows her should send her a link. Jdarg?


I think in a perfect world, yes it would be great to see Ms. Anderson on here too, but she is still running a school district during this campaign season. Remember it is against all rules to campaign during work hours so her time is very limited, remember she is a 12 month employee and doesn't have summers off like others in the race.
rocketmanBeach Comber
#12
For me, the choice for superintendent is very, very clear. During Carlene Anderson's four years as superintendent, we have witnessed our school district evolve into one of the top 5 performing districts in the state of Florida. We have come a long way in a short amount of time. My thoughts are, that we will become number one in the state in the very near future. With that being said, let's give Ms. Anderson the opportunity to continue being our superintendent.

Respectfully,
Rocketman.....
ckhagen avatar
ckhagenBeach Fanatic
#13
Like, I said, I don't know what the issues are... I don't know what these things are that someone would oppose that would in turn cause them to fear their job security. I never spoke to employees, just parents who knew employees. I do know that many people are concerned about the way she handles homeschooling families and like it or not, that's part of her job. The point is, I think someone needs to get to the bottom of these issues because they're definitely there, it just seems like no one is willing to talk, all for the same reasons.
SantiagoBeach Fanatic
#14
The choice is easy in the Superintendent's race. The choice is easy for me. Carlene Anderson.

The school board is used to working with her, and we will only have 1 new school board member (as I imagine Mark Davis will and should be re-elected), and if Robert Nelson wins the other board position, then he has been to so many school board meetings and has been uber-involved with the school system over the years to jump right in and work with her. I guess what I am trying to say that I would see the start of the year as fairly seamless on both sides if Carlene gets re-elected- no down time for a learning curve.

I have only heard teachers speak well of her south of the bay, our test scores went up, we have some schools making great improvements, and overall our district seems to be improving - so why rock the boat? I say give her more years to show us what she can do. A change here would just slow up progress at this point, IMO. There is no good reason to replace her at this time.

Using this logic, why should anyone new ever be elected to any position? Learning curve?, By the looks of some of the people that have represented us in both the school board and commission, the learning curve can't be that difficult.
Jdarg avatar
JdargSoWal Expert
#15
Using this logic, why should anyone new ever be elected to any position? Learning curve?, By the looks of some of the people that have represented us in both the school board and commission, the learning curve can't be that difficult.

But what about "if it ain't broke, why fix it?" I don't think the superintendent's office is in terrible shape, and I think Carlene Anderson deserves another term to keep moving forward and making positive changes.

Yes, improvements can always be made. I just don't think Carlene Anderson needs to be replaced. For several reasons, including the ones mentioned.
SantiagoBeach Fanatic
#16
But what about "if it ain't broke, why fix it?" I don't think the superintendent's office is in terrible shape, and I think Carlene Anderson deserves another term to keep moving forward and making positive changes.

Yes, improvements can always be made. I just don't think Carlene Anderson needs to be replaced. For several reasons, including the ones mentioned.

I'm with you on the superintendent, I just don't think they're being used to each other is a reason to vote for her or the board. I'm used to my ex wife, but I still think she is a b--ch. As far as improvements, it looks like one has been made at Bay Elementary with Dr. Pettis returning as principal.
itsmeBeach Comber
#17
Although her methods have been questioned she has put quality principals in our school. This has reflected in the grades of those schools. Since my mother is one, I well know teachers can be a honory bunch sometimes. She has patted herself on the back a few time, but its nothing don gates didn't do. At least she is not running for senate.
Seeker1Beach Lover
#18
no on anderson

Ever since anderson was placed into office she has acted like royalty. She has never ever returned a single phone call to my home. Granted I've called for her assistance only five or six times over the years but is there a minimum before you get treated with respect? I have heard the same complaint from others. Still, others say she returns calls. I have narrowed it down to her refusing to return calls on matters relating to each particular issue. if its an issue the parent wants action on something she agrees with then the call has been made. If its over a decision she has made, or lack thereof, then its no return call. From calls to two personal noted left for her at her office my family has been shown no respect. At least have SOMEONE make a return call.
Anderson? Nope! And stop with the school grading people! Get over that political fodder! FCAT is a joke and holds no substance but gives people like anderson a flag to waive.
Hey look, lower the standards and any school will accell. Kids graduate today that cant write. They cant understand how to balance a checkbook or read a telephone bill or understand a job application. Overall our entire school system is weak. Its not Andersons fault by any means. But just meeting a minimum standard is no achievement. Im leaning towards porter who has her sights on a better future and higher goals for our children.

Edited

idlewindBeach Fanatic
#19
Ever since anderson was placed into office she has acted like royalty. She has never ever returned a single phone call to my home. granted Iv called for her assistance only five or six times over the years but is there a minimum before you get treated with respect? I have heard the same complaint from others. Still, others say she returns calls. I have narrowed it down to her refusing to return calls on matters relating to each particular issue. if its an issue the parent wants action on something she agrees with then the call has been made. If its over a decision she has made, or lack thereof, then its no return call. From calls to two personal noted left for her at her office my family has been shown no respect.
Anderson? Nope! And stop with the school grading people! Get over that political fodder! FCAT is a joke and holds no substance but gives people like anderson a flag to waive.
Hey look, lower the standards and any school will accell. kids graduate today that cant write. cant understand how to balance a checkbook or read a telephone bill or understand a job application. Overall our entire school system is weak. Its not Andersons fault by any means. But just meeting a minimum standard is no achievement. Im leaning towards porter who has her sights on a better future and higher goals for our children.


Dear Friend, I get that you don't like her, and I am the first to admit I don't know as much as I should about the school district. :idontno: However, the consensus is that the schools have improved over the last four years and the principal at South Walton is a good man who is doing great things. :clap: So what is the other candidate going to do to make things even better? I want to be fair and have not made my mind up, but someone is going to have to give me a better reason than she "acts like royalty" pretty darn't quick. :confused:
elephantmanBeach Crab
#20
Ever since anderson was placed into office she has acted like royalty. She has never ever returned a single phone call to my home. Granted I've called for her assistance only five or six times over the years but is there a minimum before you get treated with respect? I have heard the same complaint from others. Still, others say she returns calls. I have narrowed it down to her refusing to return calls on matters relating to each particular issue. if its an issue the parent wants action on something she agrees with then the call has been made. If its over a decision she has made, or lack thereof, then its no return call. From calls to two personal noted left for her at her office my family has been shown no respect. At least have SOMEONE make a return call.
Anderson? Nope! And stop with the school grading people! Get over that political fodder! FCAT is a joke and holds no substance but gives people like anderson a flag to waive.
Hey look, lower the standards and any school will accell. Kids graduate today that cant write. They cant understand how to balance a checkbook or read a telephone bill or understand a job application. Overall our entire school system is weak. Its not Andersons fault by any means. But just meeting a minimum standard is no achievement. Im leaning towards porter who has her sights on a better future and higher goals for our children.

In regards to her acting like royalty I have never found that to be true. From reading her bio she passed out the other night at the Emerald Coast Realtor?s Association Forum I see she worked her way up through the ranks beginning as a teachers' aid to where she is now. If you disagree with the school grading system and FCAT, call Tallahassee, they created it!! Agree with FCAT or not, our district seems to look good statewide. Based on Ms. Hutchinson?s own words from the Emerald Coast Realtor's Association forum the other night her platform to improve the WCSD is to have an open door policy, return phone calls, and work like a "team". Those are management techniques, not educational strategies, so if you want an educator with strong management skills vote for Anderson, if you want a Secretary vote for Hutchinson.

Checking your forum account

Please wait while we verify your forum account.