Back to Food & Dining

Chicago-style Hot Dogs

drsvelte avatar
drsvelteBeach Fanatic
9,289 views
When I was a kid, I loved hot dogs. I ate them all the way thru college as a way to extend the budget. But when I became an adult, I put away my childish things, which included hot dogs. Until recently, I probably have eaten no more than 10 hot dogs in the last thirty years or so. Mostly because of the, um, unsavory health reputation they had garnered. 😱 However, a couple of years ago I had an epiphany of sorts and decided to grill some dogs for the Fourth of July. These were garden variety dogs ? dressed only by Heinz ketchup and Kraft yellow mustard. We liked them so much we started to incorporate hot dogs more into meals ? chili dogs, kraut dogs, etc. In my search for the GREATEST hog dog I came across the venerated Chicago Dog.

?A Chicago Style Hot Dog is more than just a Hot Dog; it's a taste sensation with the perfect blend of toppings. A Chicago Style Hot Dog is a steamed all beef Hot Dog topped with yellow mustard, bright green relish, onions, tomato wedges, pickle spear or slice, sport peppers and a dash of celery salt served in the all-important steamed poppy seed bun.?

Ingredients

1. Hot Dogs (Best?s Kosher, Klement?s Beef or Oscar Mayer Deli Style are all rated excellent)
2. Yellow Mustard (French?s or Plochman?s)
3. Relish (Rolf?s ?Deli Style? Sweet Pickle Relish or Sweet Super Green Pickle Relish from the Puckered Pickle Company)
4. Onions (Vidalia or Texas Sweet)
5. Tomato Wedges (Creole or beefsteak)
6. Pickle Spear (Crunchy Deli Pickle Spears from the Puckered Pickle Company or Claussen?s Kosher Deli Spears are recommended)
7. Sport Peppers (Dell? Alpe, Il Primo or Alpino are recommended brands)
8. Celery Salt (don?t forget this ? its makes a surprising difference)
9. Poppy Seed Buns (Instead, I use Pepperidge Farms Hoagie Rolls which are sesame seed)

I never thought I would find the recommended pickle relish or the sport peppers in South Louisiana. We have the Mayer?s Deli dogs and somewhat amazingly, Albertsons stocks the Puckered Pickle Relish (a bright vibrant neon green!) and the Alpino sport peppers (these peppers are some hot and I remove the seeds). Just today, I found the Puckered Pickle Company?s Crunchy Deli Pickle Spears at a local Italian grocery! They are indeed crunchy and not as sour as Claussen?s -- they're good!. (The Publix at Sandestin has sport peppers but not the pickles or relish).

Assembling the Chicago Dog

The following is from: www.hotdogchicagostyle.com/makeyourown.php

?A Chicago Style hot dog is slowly simmered using steam heat until the hot dog reaches approximately 170-180 degrees. Although steam is the preferred method, grilling, heating in water or using the microwave are also acceptable.?
?The toppings are just as important as the order they are applied to the Hot Dog. The goal is to evenly distribute the toppings so you get a taste of each ingredient with every bite. Remember, dress the Dog and not the bun! Start out by placing your heated Hot Dog on the bun and add the toppings in the following order:?

1. Squirt the mustard directly on the dog from one end to the other.
2. Add a generous amount of sweet relish.
3. Then place onions on top of the dog.
4. The tomatoes should be placed along the crevice between between the top of the bun and the hot dog.
5. The pickle should be placed in the crevice between the bottom of the bun and the hot dog.
6. Traditionally two sport peppers are added on top of a Chicago Dog, but the sport pepper is often considered an optional topping.
7. Sprinkle a dash of celery salt over the dog.
8. Enjoy!! 😀

These are great dogs! Please share any favorite hot dog recipes you may have.

Replies

33
Carol G avatar
Carol GBeach Fanatic
#2
<<<------- Chicago native, your post has me drooling! :drool: Thanks for the recipe, you got it just right.

If you want to see someone make a really great face, go to a Chicago hot dog stand and order a hot dog with ketchup... :lol:
wrobert avatar
wrobertBeach Fanatic
#3
<<<------- Chicago native, your post has me drooling! :drool: Thanks for the recipe, you got it just right.

If you want to see someone make a really great face, go to a Chicago hot dog stand and order a hot dog with ketchup... :lol:


For what it is worth. H&M Hot Dogs on 9th St in DeFuniak Springs makes a mean Chicago style hot dog. That was the first place I ever had one, and I have been a convert ever since, now I know where to get the fixins' to do it at home.

Thanks!
DD avatar
DDSoWal Expert
#4
I'm not a huge fan of hot dogs either, but that looks pretty delish!
Carol G avatar
Carol GBeach Fanatic
#5
I'm not a huge fan of hot dogs either, but that looks pretty delish!

Ditto... it's one of those things that I almost never eat, but every once in a great while I get a craving that MUST be satisfied, and only a real Chicago dog will do.
DD avatar
DDSoWal Expert
#6
Ditto... it's one of those things that I almost never eat, but every once in a great while I get a craving that MUST be satisfied, and only a real Chicago dog will do.

Congrats on your move!!! :clap:
Carol G avatar
Carol GBeach Fanatic
#7
For what it is worth. H&M Hot Dogs on 9th St in DeFuniak Springs makes a mean Chicago style hot dog.

Yum, I'll have to make a lunch trip to DFS one day, thanks!
Carol G avatar
Carol GBeach Fanatic
#8
Congrats on your move!!! :clap:

Thank you! I am so excited... I've been mentally decorating my new place in my mind for two days now, I've got to stop and start focusing on packing!!!
DD avatar
DDSoWal Expert
#9
Thank you! I am so excited... I've been mentally decorating my new place in my mind for two days now, I've got to stop and start focusing on packing!!!

Where ya movin' to?
Carol G avatar
Carol GBeach Fanatic
#10
Where ya movin' to?

A townhouse off 30A, but I'm not really which "town" I'm in (somehow I managed to *ignore* the new great big blue signs in all my excitement :lol: ). Eastern end of Seagrove, but it's a PCB mailing address, go figure.
DD avatar
DDSoWal Expert
#11
A townhouse off 30A, but I'm not really which "town" I'm in (somehow I managed to *ignore* the new great big blue signs in all my excitement :lol: ). Eastern end of Seagrove, but it's a PCB mailing address, go figure.

Oh I know! From time to time, I mail things to that area and the address is always PCB or Santa Rosa Beach, no matter what town it is. :idontno:
RudyjohnSoWal Insider
#12
Thank you! I am so excited... I've been mentally decorating my new place in my mind for two days now, I've got to stop and start focusing on packing!!!
I say congratulations too!

But to me (NOT being a native Chicagoan but Mr. JR IS) a hot dog is a hot dog. I've had the real thing but I guess you just have to be raised with the real thing. I'm totally fine with any old dog.

So WaterCourseWay, what part of Chicago are you from?
Carol G avatar
Carol GBeach Fanatic
#13
I say congratulations too!

But to me (NOT being a native Chicagoan but Mr. JR IS) a hot dog is a hot dog. I've had the real thing but I guess you just have to be raised with the real thing. I'm totally fine with any old dog.

So WaterCourseWay, what part of Chicago are you from?

Thanks! I grew up in the West 'burbs (Lombard) then moved to the city after college; I lived in Wrigleyville and Wicker Park for a few years each, and one year in Evanston (not really the city, but still fun and on the El.)

I'm a fairly well traveled person; I've been to New York, London, Paris, Rome, Moscow and a whole bunch of smaller cities around the globe, so I can say (with some authority and very prejudiced conviction) that Chicago is the greatest city in the world! :lol:
RudyjohnSoWal Insider
#14
Thanks! I grew up in the West 'burbs (Lombard) then moved to the city after college; I lived in Wrigleyville and Wicker Park for a few years each, and one year in Evanston (not really the city, but still fun and on the El.)

I'm a fairly well traveled person; I've been to New York, London, Paris, Rome, Moscow and a whole bunch of smaller cities around the globe, so I can say (with some authority and very prejudiced conviction) that Chicago is the greatest city in the world! :lol:
We're in Evanston once a week at Northwestern for my son's music. I would LOVE to live there. I love Chicago too, but Sowal would be better.

Good luck to you! You are moving at the best time - Feb can be brutal.
Carol G avatar
Carol GBeach Fanatic
#15
Good luck to you! You are moving at the best time - Feb can be brutal.

Thank you for the well wishes and good luck, but I'm only moving from Fort Walton Beach, I migrated here from Chicago in 2003. I miss the city, and four definite seasons, but I DO NOT miss Chicago Februaries... or Marches or Aprils either, for that matter.

Sounds like you guys might have to make a 'lil getaway to SoWal come February... if the weather keeps up the way it's been lately, it will probably be in the 80's by then!
seaside2 avatar
seaside2Beach Fanatic
#16
:wub:Love them Chicago dogs!!! :wub::wub:Used to work for a company based in C, and couldn't wait to get me a C dog as soon as I got there.😀
supermom262 avatar
supermom262Beach Fanatic
#17
That is my husband's favorite hot dog! He is an aficionado of hot dogs! We even went to a hot dog eating contest in Atlanta!

It is his dream to have a hot dog stand! Who knows if it will ever happen!
barefootguy avatar
barefootguyBeach Fanatic
#18
Hey WaterCourseWay, I grew up in Lombard also. Graduated from Willowbrook in '83. My brother followed your path into the city and I moved around the suburbs. Lived in Villa Park, Wheaton, Glen Ellyn, Elmhurst, Bloomingdale, Carol Stream, Cary, Lake in the Hills -- I guess you could say I like to move. I've been down here for almost 3 years and have moved 3 times. The problem here is I can't sell the homes so I have to slow down a bit. After our last move our daughter suggested we just keep the empty boxes in the garage for the next move. She's 7 and has moved 6 times.

Anyway, welcome to the area!

Thanks! I grew up in the West 'burbs (Lombard) then moved to the city after college; I lived in Wrigleyville and Wicker Park for a few years each, and one year in Evanston (not really the city, but still fun and on the El.)

I'm a fairly well traveled person; I've been to New York, London, Paris, Rome, Moscow and a whole bunch of smaller cities around the globe, so I can say (with some authority and very prejudiced conviction) that Chicago is the greatest city in the world! :lol:
Carol G avatar
Carol GBeach Fanatic
#19
Hey WaterCourseWay, I grew up in Lombard also. Graduated from Willowbrook in '83. My brother followed your path into the city and I moved around the suburbs. Lived in Villa Park, Wheaton, Glen Ellyn, Elmhurst, Bloomingdale, Carol Stream, Cary, Lake in the Hills -- I guess you could say I like to move. I've been down here for almost 3 years and have moved 3 times. The problem here is I can't sell the homes so I have to slow down a bit. After our last move our daughter suggested we just keep the empty boxes in the garage for the next move. She's 7 and has moved 6 times.

Anyway, welcome to the area!

Ha - I graduated from Willowbrook in '88! Small world... I know what you mean about moving so much; in between Chicago stints I lived in Salt Lake City, UT and Monterey, CA, plus I moved to Ft. Walton twice before this last, final time. That's why I decided to buy my condo when I did, I knew it would tame my wanderlust & keep me in one place for a while anyway... all that packing & unpacking wears you out. My feet have been itching to leave for the last 3 out of 4 years of ownership; I've learned that renting is probably a better choice for me!

Thanks for the welcome, hope we run into each other in the *real* world and get to share hometown stories...
Carol G avatar
Carol GBeach Fanatic
#20
I was watching TV at my parents' house tonight and my mother, who has no idea about this thread or forum, said to me "you know what I've been craving? A real Chicago hot dog, I'd give anything for one right now!"
Cracked me up... :lol:

Checking your forum account

Please wait while we verify your forum account.