Back to Food & Dining

Which on your 'Wich?

DD avatar
SoWal Expert
7,556 views
Mayo or Miracle Whip?

It's a long standing argument in the DD house.

Replies

52
kathydwells avatar
Darlene is my middle name, not my nickname
#2
Mayo! Hellman's....the only kind.:wave:
beachmouse avatar
Beach Fanatic
#3
Neither. I don't like the 'egginess' of mayo and will substitute ranch dressing if the sandwich seems to need a white sauce on it.
Beach Fanatic
#4
miracle whip on BLT (cut the T), real mayo (preferably herbed) on turkey, prefer real on ham but can tolerate miracle whip. Burgers are mustard only however!!
Rita avatar
margarita brocolia
#5
.
Either - but I like a spicy mustard with it... :wave:




.
DD avatar
SoWal ExpertAuthor
#6
I think I've asked this before, but y'all know how my memory is. Mr. DD has to have MW on both slices of bread. To me, MW is too sweet. This from one who has sampled numerous candy samples this weekend. :roll:
Rita avatar
margarita brocolia
#7
I think I've asked this before, but y'all know how my memory is. Mr. DD has to have MW on both slices of bread. To me, MW is too sweet. This from one who has sampled numerous candy samples this weekend. :roll:
.
It is definitely sweeter. I grew up on miracle whip so don't think much about it. I like to use it when making tuna/egg salad and especially on my BLT sandwich.



.
iwishiwasthere avatar
Beach Fanatic
#8
MW... Mayo for special occasions.
Sheila avatar
SoWal Insider
#9
Mayo all the way! Although our daughter used to love a Miracle Whip and bologna sandwich. (yuck!). I agree with DD, way too sweet. It's like smearing marshmallow fluff on your sandwich.
DD avatar
SoWal ExpertAuthor
#10
Mayo all the way! Although our daughter used to love a Miracle Whip and bologna sandwich. (yuck!). I agree with DD, way too sweet. It's like smearing marshmallow fluff on your sandwich.

Thank you. :D
Franny avatar
Beach Fanatic
#11
I agree, too sweet. Kraft Mayo or Dukes for me!:wave:
sunspotbaby avatar
SoWal Insider
#12
No argument in our house. We all hate the Whip! :wave:
scooterbug44 avatar
SoWal Expert
#13
Neither - I use butter!

Not a fan of slimy sandwiches!
Lynnie avatar
SoWal Insider
#14
Dukes or Hellmans.....full fat. No Miracle Whip here.
Beach Runner avatar
beats on hood
#15
I use Kraft Light Mayo -- not my favorite, but I'd rather use my calories and fat grams elsewhere. Never liked Miracle Whip. I like Grey Poupon on ham sandwiches.

Hubby despises mayonnaise and ketchup. He likes mustard however.

Edited

Andy A avatar
Beach Fanatic
#16
The same argument goes on in our house. I like mayo and my wife is a Miracle Whip fan although she prefers my homemade mayo to either one.
DuneAHH avatar
Beach Fanatic
#17
Which on the 'Wich is dependent on What 'Wich it is! :D
lms47 avatar
Beach Lover
#18
Mayo and it MUST be Hellman's.
Jdarg avatar
SoWal Expert
#20
Mayo only. I have Miracle Whip nightmares after watching my dad make equal parts SPAM and Whip sandwiches.

It is funny that some of you Southerners like the Whip. I thought it was a northern thing- my mom grew up in Minneapolis and Erie, and we only had Miracle Whip growing up. Mayo was a delicacy I could only get at a neighbor's house!
Rita avatar
margarita brocolia
#21
Mayo only. I have Miracle Whip nightmares after watching my dad make equal parts SPAM and Whip sandwiches.

It is funny that some of you Southerners like the Whip. I thought it was a northern thing- my mom grew up in Minneapolis and Erie, and we only had Miracle Whip growing up. Mayo was a delicacy I could only get at a neighbor's house!
.
..But spam and MW rightly go together!..

Your Dad's sandwich sounds good right now..............




.
Jdarg avatar
SoWal Expert
#22
.
..But spam and MW rightly go together!..

Your Dad's sandwich sounds good right now..............




.

The SPAM gene did not pass down a generation.

When are y'all coming to SOWAl next? Maybe we can grab a sandwich- anything but the SPAM though!
Rita avatar
margarita brocolia
#23
The SPAM gene did not pass down a generation.

When are y'all coming to SOWAl next? Maybe we can grab a sandwich- anything but the SPAM though!
.
When Bill is out of town sometimes I fry Spam slices for myself. Not very often but one of those "craving" kind of things. :lol:

We'll likely come spring or summer. We have to keep that pine mulch fresh for the HOA Nazis. jk

We're going to Universal Studios to see the HP exhibit in January. :clap:





.
CastlesOfSand avatar
Beach Fanatic
#24
Mayo, Hellmans, but I really like spicy mustard or just French's mustard.
Beach Runner avatar
beats on hood
#25
Which on the 'Wich is dependent on What 'Wich it is! :D
What if you're having a simple mayonnaise sandwich on fresh white bread?
DuneAHH avatar
Beach Fanatic
#26
What if you're having a simple mayonnaise sandwich on fresh white bread?

in 'wich case the 'dressing' would be:
thin sliced turkey & cucumber

whereas a simple Whip-n-white-'wich would be dressed with wonderful ripe tomato slices

'wich ever: :drool:

Checking your forum account

Please wait while we verify your forum account.