Kelly is rocking!

She was good...but damn...she's dumb!

She was good...but damn...she's dumb!

You're so bad :lol: . Also liked Katherine.

Wow, very impressed with Kelly Pickler on AI. Didn't think she had it in her, :clap_1:

I thought she did pretty good too. Didn't :wub: any of the songs:roll: , but the vocals were amazingly good for the most part considering they had such difficult tunes.

She was good...but damn...she's dumb!

:lolabove: ITA!

She was good...but damn...she's dumb!

Right on Kimmi :clap_1:

So who's going tonight? Paris? I think maybe. I agree with Simon, I thought it was weird. My daughter will be sad, she likes Paris.

Taylor was the most entertaining. Funny how he missed the mike kick tho. We rewound that a few times. :lol:

I was really looking forward to hearing Chris sing Queen but I din't like the song choice.

Queen and Elliott don't mix. IMO

Kelly....just don't like her, but she did better than I thought with Bohemian Rhapsody.

Bucky, I like him but wish he would enunciate more. It all sounds too mumbly.

Kathryn...I like her more and more, not that crazy about the song this week but good for her.

Ace...not so good this week but I hope he stays a little longer. I know he can do better!

I feel like the odd girl out here. I actually thought Elliot was the best last night. I thought Kelly was downright silly and should never have attempted that song. Really, IMO, that song should be left alone by everyone who's not Freddy Mercury!
And Paris, well...it was kind of odd seeing her in that mode, but I thought it was kind of funn to see her be so different, and I thought she looked great!
katie blue, where are yoooou?!

I really think it's up in the air tonight, any one of them could get the boot.....
I felt that there wasnt a showstopper in the bunch :idontno:

I could hardly watch it last night. They aren't improving. I might not watch anymore. But, I still love Chris (and the eyeliner he wore last night...that was so Dave Navarro.)

I could hardly watch it last night. They aren't improving. I might not watch anymore. But, I still love Chris (and the eyeliner he wore last night...that was so Dave Navarro.)

:clap_1: I know! He walked out, and I was like--whoa! Eye makeup, duuuuude! Dave Navarro is my guilty crush.
Found a good article about last night:
http://www.ew.com/ew/article/commentary/0,6115,1182742_3_0_,00.html

I think Paris, Bucky, or McPhee will go, but it's getting really hard to predict now. I was sure that Mandisa would have been in the final 3 and was shocked that she was voted off. And there's that website that encourages people to vote for the worst person and they've selected Kellie Pickler this week. See http://www.votefortheworst.com/ . I truly wish they wouldn't do that.

Personally, I was fine seeing Kellie in her goth attire and thought she did fine. I like Elliot and McPhee least of all (and didn't see Bucky).

So who's going tonight? Paris? I think maybe. I agree with Simon, I thought it was weird. My daughter will be sad, she likes Paris.

Taylor was the most entertaining. Funny how he missed the mike kick tho. We rewound that a few times. :lol:

I was really looking forward to hearing Chris sing Queen but I din't like the song choice.

Queen and Elliott don't mix. IMO

Kelly....just don't like her, but she did better than I thought with Bohemian Rhapsody.

Bucky, I like him but wish he would enunciate more. It all sounds too mumbly.

Kathryn...I like her more and more, not that crazy about the song this week but good for her.

Ace...not so good this week but I hope he stays a little longer. I know he can do better!

You're right on with my thoughts exactly Ocean.
Funny Paula, you say that cause I tried to vote for kelly and Kathryn (coundn't remember Chris' number) last night and couldn't hardly get into Kelly's number but Kathryn's I got to several times. :idontno:
Don't know what the website's agenda is but it might be doing what they're trying to do.

The website predicted Chris would be #1, and that maybe Taylor and Elliot have a chance. I would vote for Chris and Taylor.

First of all....Elliott is just so awkward. That word is awkward. He just doesn't move very naturally on the stage. I can't quite figure out his niche.

I really enjoyed the show last night. Ace was the worst in MHO.

Taylor was so cute! I love him.
I even like Kellie and definitely liked Paris.
Bucky seemed more natural and comfortable.
Katharine----great!
Chris, I actually liked even though the song was wierd.

That's all.

Paris or Bucky-one will be a spectator after tonight. I bet. Maybe. :(

Mcphee has a beautiful voice - potential there, but too Striesand-like, I think. I acutally like the sound of Bucky's voice, but he's no American Idol. I still like Taylor but most midwesterners around here don't care for him at all. I don't quite get it. They think he's too quirky with a lot of involuntary spasms. I still think he has a good voice and great personality and smile.

I bet you a McEwans at Borago that Paris wins it all. :idontno:

I'll take that bet.....mine is on Chris. :idontno:

I'll take that bet.....mine is on Chris. :idontno:

So who buys if neither Chris or Paris wins?