Back to SoWal Lounge

House Democrats Not to take Obama/GOP tax bill

beachFoolBeach Fanatic
2,311 views
House Democrats Spurn Obama-GOP Tax-Cut Deal : It's All Politics : NPR

And they think they will get a better deal next month?


:rolling::rolling::rolling::rolling:

Replies

55
BeachSiO2 avatar
BeachSiO2Beach Fanatic
#27
It looks like the time is near...

Liberals giving up tax fight - TheHill.com

A House liberal who has led the effort to stop President Obama?s tax compromise with the GOP says efforts to change the package are futile.

Rep. Peter Welch (D-Vt.), who just a week ago circulated a letter signed by 54 Democrats urging opposition to the deal, now says the ?die is cast.?
BeachSiO2 avatar
BeachSiO2Beach Fanatic
#30
The Senate just passed Stimulus II on a bipartisan 83-15 vote.

Huge Senate majority votes to advance $858B tax-cut package - TheHill.com

Oh, woops, that was just to kill a fillibuster by Mr. Sanders.

And it was last night ;-)

OTOH the Senate Dems did just introduce a 1.1T Omnibus bill to fund government through September. The funny part of it is that last year House GOP members were not allowed to ask for any earmarks, but the Senate GOP was. Now the entire GOP caucus is taking a two-year moratorium. If this bill passes a number of Senate GOP earmarks will get funded. However, if it goes as a Continuing Resolution, none of the Senate GOP earmarks would get funded. So, are the Senate GOP members going to vote for their earmarks or against them. Sure makes things fun!
30ashopper avatar
30ashopperSoWal Insider
#31
And it was last night ;-)

OTOH the Senate Dems did just introduce a 1.1T Omnibus bill to fund government through September. The funny part of it is that last year House GOP members were not allowed to ask for any earmarks, but the Senate GOP was. Now the entire GOP caucus is taking a two-year moratorium. If this bill passes a number of Senate GOP earmarks will get funded. However, if it goes as a Continuing Resolution, none of the Senate GOP earmarks would get funded. So, are the Senate GOP members going to vote for their earmarks or against them. Sure makes things fun!

How do you find this stuff out so fast? 😀
Matt J avatar
Matt JSWGB
#32
How do you find this stuff out so fast? 😀

Intertubes 😀
beachFoolBeach FanaticAuthor
#33
Someone please explain to me why there is a tax on income for which tax has already been paid?
The American Dream for many, is to become wealthy, be well known or be a celebrity. There is certainly nothing wrong with those aspirations. If you reach such a goal, why should you be penalized for attaining it? I see nothing wrong with becoming rich. I do see something terribly amiss in exhorbinately taxing someone for what they made in their life and wish to leave to their heirs. I do not have a problem with the law at 5 million. Many small businesses, particularly farms, are left to heirs who find they cannot provide the cash for the "death tax" without selling the assets being inheirited. That should not be. A little fairness in retaining what one has acquired is all that should be asked.

Andy, you should not make stuff up.

Speaking anecdotally as a farm owner it is a complete and total myth that family farms are lost due to the inheritance tax.

It does not happen.

The reality is family farms are lost due to incompetence or bad business decisions by succeeding generations. In my family, alcohol cost heirs WAY more than any estate tax.

A few years ago I asked my dad, who begin a career as a consultant forester after being discharged from the Marine Corps in 1954, if he had any clients who had to sell timberland due to the estate tax.

Negative, zip, zero, nada

So in approximately 1/2 a century he knew of no instances where the estate tax caused heirs to lose their land.

Family farms/small businesses being impacted by the estate tax is a ruse. For instance, there are several sections of the tax code where farms get relief from estate taxes.

It is true small businesses and farms who do a poor job of planning pay more estate taxes. As a financial professional that falls into the category of bad business decisions.

Personally, the estate tax exemption due to impact estates in 2011 thanks to the Bush tax cuts was/is much too low.

Edited

BeachSiO2 avatar
BeachSiO2Beach Fanatic
#34
How do you find this stuff out so fast? 😀
I work on Christmas Tree ornaments and am watching one that is on the current Omnibus tree. ;-)

Here's an update on the tax vote...

The Senate will vote shortly after noon Wednesday on final passage of the $858 billion tax deal forged by President Obama and Senate Republicans.
BeachSiO2 avatar
BeachSiO2Beach Fanatic
#35
Update from the Senate..

A sweeping tax package negotiated by the White House and GOP leaders sailed through the Senate on a 81-19 vote Wednesday and now awaits action by the House as early as Thursday.
Andy A avatar
Andy ABeach Fanatic
#36
Andy, you should not make stuff up.

Sorry, but I am only quoting what I've been told and, while I'm not a financial wizard or advisor, I realize that when you take something from someone who has earned or inheirited it, it is wrong! Just one American's opinion and I apologize for the fact it differs from anyone else's but it is a right I have as do all American citizens.
Smiling JOe avatar
Smiling JOeSoWal Expert
#37
I find it appropriate that this bill is coming around at Christmas time because after all the ornaments get hung this will be one huge tree with something for everyone to get the votes.
I noticed that the White House has a really large tree, but I didn't know that it would hold 6400+ ornaments. :roll:
30ashopper avatar
30ashopperSoWal Insider
#38
Andy, you should not make stuff up.

Speaking anecdotally as a farm owner it is a complete and total myth that family farms are lost due to the inheritance tax.

It does not happen.

The reality is family farms are lost due to incompetence or bad business decisions by succeeding generations. In my family, alcohol cost heirs WAY more than any estate tax.

A few years ago I asked my dad, who begin a career as a consultant forester after being discharged from the Marine Corps in 1954, if he had any clients who had to sell timberland due to the estate tax.

Negative, zip, zero, nada

So in approximately 1/2 a century he knew of no instances where the estate tax caused heirs to lose their land.

Family farms/small businesses being impacted by the estate tax is a ruse. For instance, there are several sections of the tax code where farms get relief from estate taxes.

It is true small businesses and farms who do a poor job of planning pay more estate taxes. As a financial professional that falls into the category of bad business decisions.

Personally, the state tax exemption due to impact estates in 2011 thanks to the Bush tax cuts was/is much too low.

It happens, 8-12% back in the late 90's. This CBO report has a wealth of data -

http://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/65xx/doc6512/07-06-EstateTax.pdf

I think the reason why liberals love this tax so much is its progressivity.
Matt J avatar
Matt JSWGB
#39
Sorry, but I am only quoting what I've been told and, while I'm not a financial wizard or advisor, I realize that when you take something from someone who has earned or inheirited it, it is wrong! Just one American's opinion and I apologize for the fact it differs from anyone else's but it is a right I have as do all American citizens.

Care to enlighten us on who told you?
beachFoolBeach FanaticAuthor
#40
Andy, you should not make stuff up.

Sorry, but I am only quoting what I've been told and, while I'm not a financial wizard or advisor, I realize that when you take something from someone who has earned or inheirited it, it is wrong! Just one American's opinion and I apologize for the fact it differs from anyone else's but it is a right I have as do all American citizens.

Think about it, Andy.

I wish there were no taxes, too.

But if there were no taxes then your government check would bounce.

The Obama plan is hardly an attack on the wealthy.

A couple can shelter up to $10M from estate taxes and with small businesses minority discounts stick another 3M on .

I thought we were all worried about the deficit :idontno:

Checking your forum account

Please wait while we verify your forum account.