Back to SoWal Lounge

Florida Political Fireworks start March 8th

30ashopper avatar
30ashopperSoWal Insider
766 views
Senate Republicans said Wednesday they are intent on making good on last fall's campaign promises -- setting the stage for a highly partisan opening week of the 2011 Legislature.

In party-line votes, the GOP-ruled Budget Committee OK'd four high-profile bills that touch on many of the issues raised by Republican Gov. Rick Scott and other Florida GOP candidates during last fall's contests.

"We have a very ambitious opening week planned," said Senate President Mike Haridopolos, R-Merritt Island. "As we promised, we're going to take our job very seriously."

Two measures approved by the budget panel would put ballot proposals before voters next year. One proposal seeks to cut Florida out of the federal health care overhaul, while the other would set a strict new spending limit on state government.

Another bill advanced Wednesday would eliminate teacher tenure, create a new teacher evaluation system and introduce merit pay, an approach generally opposed by the state's largest teachers' union, a big Democratic base.

Rounding out the ripped-from-the-campaign-trail ideas: a product liability bill opposed by Democratic-allied trial lawyers.

Senate GOP sets campaign pledges up for early votes when session starts

The tenure bill, a reincarnate of SB6, is breezing through sub-committees on it's way to the floor -

Despite pleas from teachers and Democratic lawmakers to hold off on bold reforms, plans to reinvent how Florida pays and evaluates its teachers soared through legislative committees Wednesday.

The new model would tie at least 50 percent of teachers' salaries and contracts to student performance, replacing a structure that values seniority and uses a last-in, first-out layoff policy.

That practice is "upside-down, illogically," said Rep. Erik Fresen, R-Miami, who introduced the bill and chairs the K-20 competitiveness committee.

The legislation would measure teacher performance based on four categories, and give principals the option to reject teachers who have not been rated highly effective or effective; end teacher contracts for those who receive two unsatisfactory evaluations in three years; give teachers hired after July 1, 2011, annual and not continuing contracts; and put teachers hired after July 1, 2014, on performance-based scales.

The House amended its measure (proposed bill 11-01) to mirror a substitute Senate bill (SB 736) that passed its final committee Wednesday morning. The measures are speeding toward Gov. Rick Scott, who has said he would sign the bill once it reaches his desk. Then-Gov. Charlie Crist famously vetoed SB 6, last year's controversial teacher tenure bill.

Changes in teacher pay, tenure are coasting through Florida House - St. Petersburg Times


Also related to this, apparently at least one Tampa area county has already embraced these changes and is in the process of implemeting them thanks to a grant -

One version of an overhaul bill passed its first House subcommittee Wednesday.

It calls for the use of student test scores to help determine teacher pay and effectiveness, and the elimination of tenure, the practice that grants teachers with seniority certain job protections.

The proposal mirrors Senate Bill 736, which was introduced this month and passed the Senate Budget Committee on Wednesday.

State Rep. Erik Fresen, a Republican from Miami, said exceptions in the House bill for the Hillsborough school district are "perfectly paired up" with the Senate version.

SB 736 largely exempted Hillsborough from the reforms because the district is more than a year ahead of the rest of the state with its overhaul, financed in part by a $100 million grant from the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.

"They're not really being exempted," Fresen said, "because, in reality, they're already doing it."

Like SB 736, the House proposal requires districts to base 50 percent of teacher evaluations on student learning gains.

Hillsborough will be allowed to continue with its new evaluations, in which learning gains account for 40 percent. The new Hillsborough standard is in place this year.

The district, like others across the state, also can forge ahead with its own evaluation tools for courses that don't have annual assessments such as the Florida Comprehensive Assessment Test.

These so-called value-added formulas are expected to debut in August.

They are necessary, education officials say, to help measure student learning gains in areas such as music, art and special education.

Hillsborough schools Superintendent MaryEllen Elia told members of the House K-20 Competitiveness Subcommittee, she appreciated that they took into account the work the district already is doing.

Overhaul of teacher reviews moves forward in Tallahassee

Sounds like it's going pretty well so far.

Replies

16
Bob avatar
BobSoWal Insider
#2
Senate GOP sets campaign pledges up for early votes when session starts

The tenure bill, a reincarnate of SB6, is breezing through sub-committees on it's way to the floor -



Changes in teacher pay, tenure are coasting through Florida House - St. Petersburg Times


Also related to this, apparently at least one Tampa area county has already embraced these changes and is in the process of implemeting them thanks to a grant -



Overhaul of teacher reviews moves forward in Tallahassee

Sounds like it's going pretty well so far.
this is a bipartison effort with feedback from those affected most, correct?
Bob avatar
BobSoWal Insider
#3
served up by a 5th amendment criminal who got a 1 percent mandate by blue collar teabaggers?? i smell impeachment/recall for the beady eyed sociopath
idlewindBeach Fanatic
#4
The teacher bill is another example of power grabbing politicians. What they should do is return the power to set these policies and standards to the local school board and allow each district to shape their program as local standards and demands dictate. What works in Dade county does not necessarily work in Okaloosa-Walton counties.
Matt J avatar
Matt JSWGB
#5
Don't worry, Florida will have sick, toothless, and borderline retarded children by 2011. GO BAGGERS!
scooterbug44 avatar
scooterbug44SoWal Expert
#6
The teacher bill is another example of power grabbing politicians. What they should do is return the power to set these policies and standards to the local school board and allow each district to shape their program as local standards and demands dictate. What works in Dade county does not necessarily work in Okaloosa-Walton counties.

I don't think reinventing the wheel in each individual district is either a good use of money or wise.

Some flexibility is needed, but overall the same system should be able to work for everyone. People drive a wide variety of vehicles, but the roads and street signs are basically the same for all.

And the example given in the article that a poor student couldn't answer a MATH question about baking muffins because she'd never baked muffins is a crock o'.

My teachers never gave me a pass because I'd never experienced the exact scenario described in a story problem - the basics are all the same.

It takes X amount of time to do Y, P and Q are the variables, and you have to find Z. Period.

And between life, books, tv, school, and the internet, there is no reason to not know anything. Any Panera, Publix, or Betty Crocker commercial shows baking FTLOC.

Not to mention that's why the teacher is there - so you can ask a question or they can explain anything odd that is part of the course materials.

Edited

CampCreekLou avatar
CampCreekLouBeach Lover
#7
Don't worry, Florida will have sick, toothless, and borderline retarded children by 2011. GO BAGGERS!

I love the civil discourse on this site. It's why I keep coming back... :wave:
30ashopper avatar
30ashopperSoWal InsiderAuthor
#8
A less rigid version of a bill that would begin merit pay for teachers and end tenure for new teachers is on a fast track to passage after it cleared the Florida Senate in a largely partisan vote on Thursday.

Just two days into the legislative session, the bill that was vetoed last year by former Gov. Charlie Crist is now headed for a floor vote in the House next week. Both chambers are controlled by Republicans and the legislation (SB 736) is strongly backed by new Republican Gov. Rick Scott.

Its key features are a merit pay plan based heavily on how well each teacher's students improve on standardized tests starting in 2014 and a ban on tenure for teachers hired after July 1, 2011.

After last year's veto, Florida won a $700 million federal Race to the Top stimulus grant for education improvement programs including merit pay. This year's bill largely mirrors the Race to the Top plan that was endorsed by all but two of the state's 67 school districts and 53 local teachers unions.

Democrats argued that requiring all districts to start merit pay is premature until results are in from an experimental plan in Hillsborough County being implemented with a $100 million grant from the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation.

Sen. Eleanor Sobel, D-Hollywood, said the state shouldn't be spending money on programs that don't have "a proven track record."

Sen. Mike Bennett, R-Bennett, replied that Florida does "have a proven track record, and the proven track record is that we're failing" because teachers haven't been held accountable.

TBO.com - Florida News From AP

I'm confused, why are democrats voting against a tenure bill embraced by the Obama administration and "endorsed by all but two of the state's 67 school districts and 53 local teachers unions"? Are they just playing politics and acting partisan?
lms47 avatar
lms47Beach Lover
#9
SO, now a good teacher's career is dependent on how the underacheiving, below-average student scores on a test and the "opinion" of a principal who may have an axe to grind with said teacher's philosophy??? How will Title I teachers, library media specialist, counselors, assistant principals, and principals be evaluated?
30ashopper avatar
30ashopperSoWal InsiderAuthor
#10
No idea, haven't read the bill. I was just surprised this was ok'd by all the schools in the state.

There's also a pilot project going right now, might be interesting to see if there's any data on how well it's doing.
rocketmanBeach Comber
#11
ESE Teachers

Hey! How about ESE teachers (Teachers of Children with Special Needs)? How will they be judged/graded/evaluated? We have the greatest and most rewarding job on the planet!

Rock on.....
Bob avatar
BobSoWal Insider
#12
SO, now a good teacher's career is dependent on how the underacheiving, below-average student scores on a test and the "opinion" of a principal who may have an axe to grind with said teacher's philosophy??? How will Title I teachers, library media specialist, counselors, assistant principals, and principals be evaluated?
this cannot be implemented fairly. the whole law is an assault by neocons/teabaggers on teachers by association via the union.
Bob avatar
BobSoWal Insider
#13
I love the civil discourse on this site. It's why I keep coming back... :wave:
yes, and up is down
Bob avatar
BobSoWal Insider
#14
Hey! How about ESE teachers (Teachers of Children with Special Needs)? How will they be judged/graded/evaluated? We have the greatest and most rewarding job on the planet!

Rock on.....
psst..they don't a ****. they just want to take take take
lms47 avatar
lms47Beach Lover
#15
In Alabama, where I taught for 27 years, the SDE piloted an evaluation system for one year. It included 1 scheduled observation and one unscheduled observation by the principal. It was a joke! The principal would walk into the classroom with a stop watch and calculate different teaching methods within a certain time frame. The system failed for many factors: not effective evaluation tool, principals didn't have the time to get all evaluations done for entire faculty, and the evaluation in no way measured the success of the student. It was a farce!
30ashopper avatar
30ashopperSoWal InsiderAuthor
#16
this cannot be implemented fairly. the whole law is an assault by neocons/teabaggers on teachers by association via the union.

Then why did every school district and the teacher's union approve of the plan? Something is amiss here. If anybody has more data on the bill or the test pilot program I'd love to see it.
scooterbug44 avatar
scooterbug44SoWal Expert
#17
I thought this was supposed to be one of the few good solutions because the teachers actually had input? :idontno:

Checking your forum account

Please wait while we verify your forum account.