.
“Traditionally, university donors have little official input into choosing the person who fills a chair they've funded.
Under the agreement with the Charles G. Koch Charitable Foundation, however, faculty only retain the illusion of control. The contract specifies that an advisory committee appointed by Koch decides which candidates should be considered. ... “
So Koch gets to choose profs who line up with his views. What’s wrong with this picture? ..:angry:
.
http://motherjones.com/mojo/2011/05/charles-koch-florida-state-academic-freedom
.
Rita
Ritamargarita brocoliaDune Allen Beach5,207 postsJoined View profileMessagemargarita brocolia
2,699 views
Replies
63beachmouse
beachmouseBeach FanaticBluewater Bay, FL3,499 postsJoined View profileMessageBeach Fanatic
Not that I don't trust you, but please provide a (within acceptable copyright law length) quote from the story since it's behind a paywall that says that the relevant faculty governing body of FSU is happy with this decision.
beachFoolbeachFoolBeach Fanatic938 postsJoined View profileMessageBeach Fanatic
It wasn't FSU then. My guess is that it was Florida Women's College which, as I remember, was the name before it became Florida State University.
----------------------------------------------------------------
Florida State College for Women to be exact.
Of course, grandmama insisted all of her daughters attend a Methodist women's college, Wesleyan.
My mother had a Wesleyan roommate from Tennessee whose high school biology book had evolution scissorred out.
Mama was a Republican who believed in evolution. You could do that back in the day.
Edited
30ashopper
30ashopperSoWal InsiderRight here!6,845 postsJoined View profileMessageSoWal Insider
Not that I don't trust you, but please provide a (within acceptable copyright law length) quote from the story since it's behind a paywall that says that the relevant faculty governing body of FSU is happy with this decision.
http://www.tampabay.com/news/busine...ns-at-florida-state-university-raises/1168680
Would the opinion of chairman of the economics department at FSU sufficiently calm your curiosity?
Edited
30ashopper
30ashopperSoWal InsiderRight here!6,845 postsJoined View profileMessageSoWal Insider
http://www.tallahassee.com/article/...y--not-Koch-Foundation--made-hiring-decisions
From what I've read, the people they hired were exactly who they were looking for in the school, and they were obviously happy it didn't cost the school (or taxpayers) a dime.
Beachmouse, not sure what happened, that was freely available an hour or so ago.
GoodWitch58GoodWitch58Beach Fanatic4,810 postsJoined View profileMessageBeach Fanatic
I really hope that the St. Pete Times reporter got the story wrong...that would mean that my school has not lost something important in the ethics area...on the other hand, the Times reporter was reporting on an OpEd piece written by two distinguished FSU professors...and I know both of them, and I would have to hear them say that the article they wrote was wrong before I would believe it.
And, what else do you expect the chairman of the department to say? He is in CYA mode about now...
And, what else do you expect the chairman of the department to say? He is in CYA mode about now...
Rita
Ritamargarita brocoliaDune Allen Beach5,207 postsJoined View profileMessagemargarita brocoliaAuthor
It wasn't FSU then. My guess is that it was Florida Women's College which, as I remember, was the name before it became Florida State University.
----------------------------------------------------------------
Florida State College for Women to be exact.
Of course, grandmama insisted all of her daughters attend a Methodist women's college, Wesleyan.
My mother had a Wesleyan roommate from Tennessee whose high school biology book had evolution scissorred out.
Mama was a Republican who believed in evolution. You could do that back in the day.
We're so lucky in TX that we have a State Board of Education that is trying to approve an online biology textbook that pushes creationism. *sarcasm*
Supposedly it attempts to justify the existence of a higher being while avoiding direct mention of God or the Bible.
Even in 2011, we're probably lucky in TX that teachers are still allowed to teach evolution. Who knows how long that will last........
poppypoppyBannedMiramar Beach2,854 postsJoined View profileMessageBanned
As usual the liberal media did not get the story right. Suprise, suprise.
The story being accurate is secondary to the fact that the argument was is it right or wrong and YOU and the other conservatives defended the practice while every liberal opposed it. Surprise, surprise.
Rita
Ritamargarita brocoliaDune Allen Beach5,207 postsJoined View profileMessagemargarita brocoliaAuthor
I really hope that the St. Pete Times reporter got the story wrong...that would mean that my school has not lost something important in the ethics area...on the other hand, the Times reporter was reporting on an OpEd piece written by two distinguished FSU professors...and I know both of them, and I would have to hear them say that the article they wrote was wrong before I would believe it.
And, what else do you expect the chairman of the department to say? He is in CYA mode about now...
I can envision the "CYA mode" kicking into high gear! This must have his department in a tailspin. This would seem to be an article that in time will be verifiable one way or the other as to facts.
poppypoppyBannedMiramar Beach2,854 postsJoined View profileMessageBanned
The whole liberal Koch witch hunt reminds me of the birther movement.
Sounds similar to the conservatives and George Soros doesn't it.
30ashopper
30ashopperSoWal InsiderRight here!6,845 postsJoined View profileMessageSoWal Insider
I really hope that the St. Pete Times reporter got the story wrong...that would mean that my school has not lost something important in the ethics area...on the other hand, the Times reporter was reporting on an OpEd piece written by two distinguished FSU professors...and I know both of them, and I would have to hear them say that the article they wrote was wrong before I would believe it.
And, what else do you expect the chairman of the department to say? He is in CYA mode about now...
Get them to join SoWal and lets have a discussion! 😀
30ashopper
30ashopperSoWal InsiderRight here!6,845 postsJoined View profileMessageSoWal Insider
The story being accurate is secondary to the fact that the argument was is it right or wrong and YOU and the other conservatives defended the practice while every liberal opposed it. Surprise, surprise.
Of course we defend it, there's nothing wrong with individuals contributing money to a university to improve the quality of education in this country.
30ashopper
30ashopperSoWal InsiderRight here!6,845 postsJoined View profileMessageSoWal Insider
Sounds similar to the conservatives and George Soros doesn't it.
No, just the birthers.
poppypoppyBannedMiramar Beach2,854 postsJoined View profileMessageBanned
Of course we defend it, there's nothing wrong with individuals contributing money to a university to improve the quality of education in this country.
Nice try but, FAIL
Rita
Ritamargarita brocoliaDune Allen Beach5,207 postsJoined View profileMessagemargarita brocoliaAuthor
Here is the op ed by Bellamy & Miller:
http://www.tallahassee.com/article/...er-Universities-deal-with-political-economics
Ray Bellamy and Kent Miller: Universities deal with political economics
"A careful reading of the memorandum reveals a number of strings attached to the "gift."
* In order to preserve and safeguard the philanthropic and educational intent of the CGK Foundation … an advisory board will be created consisting of three members … chosen by CGK Foundation.
* The three senior professors must come in with tenure, and FSU must continue to fund them for at least four years past the project period.
* The Advisory Board of SPSFC and EEE is allowed to review all publicly provided material submitted by applicants for the Professorship positions.
* The Advisory Board will determine which candidates qualify to receive funding.
* No funding for a professorship position or any other affiliated program or position will be released without the review and approval of the Advisory Board.
* An undergraduate program will be devised and funded for $30,000 per year for three years. The committee responsible for the program will report to the Advisory Board.
Other strings spell out the right of the CGK Foundation to annually review the work of funded professors, publications, publicity, etc., and to pick up their marbles and go home if not satisfied.
We see all of this as seriously damaging to academic freedom."
http://www.tallahassee.com/article/...er-Universities-deal-with-political-economics
Ray Bellamy and Kent Miller: Universities deal with political economics
"A careful reading of the memorandum reveals a number of strings attached to the "gift."
* In order to preserve and safeguard the philanthropic and educational intent of the CGK Foundation … an advisory board will be created consisting of three members … chosen by CGK Foundation.
* The three senior professors must come in with tenure, and FSU must continue to fund them for at least four years past the project period.
* The Advisory Board of SPSFC and EEE is allowed to review all publicly provided material submitted by applicants for the Professorship positions.
* The Advisory Board will determine which candidates qualify to receive funding.
* No funding for a professorship position or any other affiliated program or position will be released without the review and approval of the Advisory Board.
* An undergraduate program will be devised and funded for $30,000 per year for three years. The committee responsible for the program will report to the Advisory Board.
Other strings spell out the right of the CGK Foundation to annually review the work of funded professors, publications, publicity, etc., and to pick up their marbles and go home if not satisfied.
We see all of this as seriously damaging to academic freedom."
Checking your forum account
Please wait while we verify your forum account.