Back to Real Estate

Calling The Bottom

Beach Fanatic
78,581 views
A couple days ago I happened to be reading an article in the Atlanta Journal regarding the market in Panama City. There was a quote from Janet Roan, a local (PC, not Atl) real estate agent - "Now is the time to buy. It's a buyer's market." But she says, "If you are looking to buy something to flip it, don't even try it right now."

The catch? That article was from April 16, 2006.

There was another guy who had put contracts on 3 units in Panama City towers, pre-construction, each in the low 200k range. The article says the prices had tripled and then fell back but were still above his contract price. He said at the time he still expected to be able to sell at a comfortable profit although they were not yet completed. He was worried at the time that they may be overdeveloping the Panama City Beach area.

I'd like to see the AJC or some other organization do some follow up stories and talk to some of the same people interviewed previously. What does that agent think now? Did that guy close on his 3 properties and sell them or did he walk from his deposits? Is he stuck in 3 condos, eating a monthly mortgage while taking in some little bit of rent?

Replies

388
flyforfun avatar
Beach Fanatic
#102
Re: The bottom has arrived

Congrats! Five years from now you are going to be kicking yourself for not buying two!:clap:

Well it must be the official bottom because I just
bought in.

PCB beachfront on a low floor (and I mean on the beach). Built in 2004/2005. About 1500 square feet finished out high end.

I predict nothing but up from this point forward.

Joking aside while I hope it is the bottom, I made the age old mistake of falling in love with a place and bought sooner than I planned. :bang:

Maybe still some downside but I am in.:D Its all about the view at happy hour!:cool:

Good luck to all,
Flyguy
SHELLY avatar
SoWal Insider
#103
Re: The bottom has arrived

Congrats! Five years from now you are going to be kicking yourself for not buying two!:clap:

How many have you bought?


.
30A Skunkape avatar
Skunky
#104
Re: The bottom has arrived

How many have you bought?


.

FFF is about quality, not quantity. Trust me.:cool:
flyforfun avatar
Beach Fanatic
#105
Re: The bottom has arrived

You know, I have a nice home on the beach, so I am now just looking for vacant land with beach views and high elevation. Bobby J keeps me posted when something pops up that fits my select criteria. I am looking for good lots close to seaside, along 30-A, with water views and beach access that are outside of the large developments. You can bet that when that right old seagrove property comes available, I am going to buy it! With amend 1's passage protecting me from the county increasing property taxes more than 10% a year, I plan on buying two lots this year. But remember, I don't buy to flip and like to hold on to my property 5-10 years. However when I find a lot that will allow you to put a trailer on it, you will be the first person I will call. If I wanted a condo, now is a good time to buy one. I just think you need to be asking alot of questions and making certain you speak with HOA President about lawsuits, assesments and if there are any pending issues with the building. I like the construction of all the new condo's being built, and feel confident most are going survive the storms with minimal to no damage.

Edited

SHELLY avatar
SoWal Insider
#106
Re: The bottom has arrived

You know, I have a nice home on the beach, so I am now just looking for vacant land with beach views and high elevation. Bobby J keeps me posted when something pops up that fits my select criteria. I am looking for good lots close to seaside, along 30-A, with water views and beach access that are outside of the large developments. You can bet that when that right old seagrove property comes available, I am going to buy it! With amend 1's passage protecting me from the county increasing property taxes more than 10% a year, I plan on buying two lots this year. But remember, I don't buy to flip and like to hold on to my property 5-10 years. However when I find a lot that will allow you to put a trailer on it, you will be the first person I will call. If I wanted a condo, now is a good time to buy one. I just think you need to be asking alot of questions and making certain you speak with HOA President about lawsuits, assesments and if there are any pending issues with the building. I like the construction of all the new condo's being built, and feel confident most are going survive the storms with minimal to no damage.

So you recommend others buy condos now lest they'll be kicking themselves in 5 years, yet you wouldn't buy them yourself....so can we conclude that you're into self-flagellation?


.
Ohio Girl avatar
Beach Lover
#107
Re: The bottom has arrived

If the bottom has arrived, why are sellers still dropping prices?
scooterbug44 avatar
SoWal Expert
#108
Re: The bottom has arrived

If the bottom has arrived, why are sellers still dropping prices?

Because it hasn't! :ninja:

Don't worry, it's still a great time to buy! :roll:
dunelover avatar
Beach Fanatic
#109
Re: The bottom has arrived

If the bottom has arrived, why are sellers still dropping prices?
Great point!! What i find interesting is the speed w/ which properties come on and off the mls.
Miss Kitty avatar
Meow
#110
Re: The bottom has arrived

I sure have been getting alot of emails from a certain real estate company announcing many sales of homes and lots in WC.
Bobby J avatar
Beach Fanatic
#111
Re: The bottom has arrived

If the bottom has arrived, why are sellers still dropping prices?

Does this mean once we are at the bottom sellers will stop dropping prices? IMO, sellers are getting a clearer picture of what it will take to sell their property. We are just going through the process.

When a property sells does that mean it was at the bottom? I have given up trying to figure it all out. We are very busy and very grateful that the market is moving. The end.....
Smiling JOe avatar
SoWal Expert
#112
Re: The bottom has arrived

a little insider data for you non-Realtors. In all of South Walton, including Miramar Bch, the pending sales for the last three months are as follows, for Residential Homes, Townhomes, and Condos, combined. Keep in mind that pending sales are simply listings which are under sales contracts. That doesn't necessarily mean that they will close. They may not. The only reason for me posting this data which is collected from Emerald Coast Assoc. of Realtors, is to show the increase in activity which has been buzzing lately. The data shows :

Pending Sales for Combined Residential Homes in South Walton:

2007
Sep - $48.5 million
Oct - $45.4 million
Nov - $52.6 million
Dec - $39.3 million

2008
Jan - $40.7 million
Feb - $88.8 million
Mar - $84.3 million
dunelover avatar
Beach Fanatic
#113
Re: The bottom has arrived

a little insider data for you non-Realtors. In all of South Walton, including Miramar Bch, the pending sales for the last three months are as follows, for Residential Homes, Townhomes, and Condos, combined. Keep in mind that pending sales are simply listings which are under sales contracts. That doesn't necessarily mean that they will close. They may not. The only reason for me posting this data which is collected from Emerald Coast Assoc. of Realtors, is to show the increase in activity which has been buzzing lately. The data shows :

Pending Sales for Combined Residential Homes in South Walton:

2007
Sep - $48.5 million
Oct - $45.4 million
Nov - $52.6 million
Dec - $39.3 million

2008
Jan - $40.7 million
Feb - $88.8 million
Mar - $84.3 million
SJ--thanks for the work on those numbers. I believe you guys when you say it is buzzing. I have also heard that sales pick up typically around spring break. So, is comparing first qtr 08, to 4th qtr 07 really accurate?
flyforfun avatar
Beach Fanatic
#114
Re: The bottom has arrived

So you recommend others buy condos now lest they'll be kicking themselves in 5 years, yet you wouldn't buy them yourself....so can we conclude that you're into self-flagellation?


.

Shelton, there are a lot of good condo buys available. But personally I don't want any more toilets to keep up with. If I did not own a condo, I would be buying one now. What is rapidly disappearing along 30-A is ocean/beach view lots outside the large developments. Once the mandated build out properties have homes sitting on them, the lots left with a view are going to rapidly increase. From an investors point of view, these are more appealing to me than a condo. J

Edited

Beach Fanatic
#115
Re: The bottom has arrived

a little insider data for you non-Realtors. In all of South Walton, including Miramar Bch, the pending sales for the last three months are as follows, for Residential Homes, Townhomes, and Condos, combined. Keep in mind that pending sales are simply listings which are under sales contracts. That doesn't necessarily mean that they will close. They may not. The only reason for me posting this data which is collected from Emerald Coast Assoc. of Realtors, is to show the increase in activity which has been buzzing lately. The data shows :

Pending Sales for Combined Residential Homes in South Walton:

2007
Sep - $48.5 million
Oct - $45.4 million
Nov - $52.6 million
Dec - $39.3 million

2008
Jan - $40.7 million
Feb - $88.8 million
Mar - $84.3 million

What were comparable numbers for Jan, Feb and March 2007? Has activity picked up versus prior year or is this simply the normal seasonal uptick in activity?

I ask this because according to the Real Trend Report ACTUAL sales of SFH's through February are actually flat with prior year at $97 million and condo sales are down by $131 million or 77%. Looks like actual sales are not picking up versus prior year and your data may indicate only the normal seasonal uptick in activity.

Edited

Smiling JOe avatar
SoWal Expert
#116
Re: The bottom has arrived

SJ--thanks for the work on those numbers. I believe you guys when you say it is buzzing. I have also heard that sales pick up typically around spring break. So, is comparing first qtr 08, to 4th qtr 07 really accurate?
My intent was to show the increase in activity during the recent months, rather than comparing quarters. I don't think the contracts written in Feb and Mar were related to Spring Break in any way.

Edited

Beach Lover
#117
Re: The bottom has arrived

If the bottom has arrived, why are sellers still dropping prices?


Here is my theory on this and why I jumped in at this point.

Most real estate is still way overpriced. Most sellers can not or will not accept where the market is. They continue to drop their prices but not enough to get to where stuff sells. Joe tracks this on his website and I am sure the majority of price decreases are from extremely overpriced to just way overpriced.

I have about 5 buildings that I really like and keep track of prices. Over the last 2+ years a chart of their actual sales prices was constantly going down. But over the last 6 months or so they have or are developing a flat line for actual sale prices. When a seller drops his price down to that line it sells almost immediately. Wether that line is the bottom of the market for that building or a lull in the decline I can't tell you.

As for me, I jumped in because a condo in my favorite building on my favorite floor dropped their asking price to that line. I made them a cash offer for considerably less. I have to tell you I was amazed they took it. But I am thrilled because I got what I wanted. And while prices may be lower in 6 months, the condo I really wanted would most likely be long gone.

JMHO,
Flyguy

Edited

Smiling JOe avatar
SoWal Expert
#118
Re: The bottom has arrived

(Source: Emerald Coast Assoc. of Realtors)

2005
Oct - $28.2 million
Nov - $71.1 million
Dec - $19.7 million
2006
Jan - $23.1 million
Feb - $25.7 million
Mar - $28.0 million
**************

2006
Oct - $43.5 million
Nov - $39.5 million
Dec - $28.8 million
2007
Jan - $48.6 million
Feb - $66.2 million
Mar - $110.3 million
***************

2007
Oct - $45.4 million
Nov - $52.6 million
Dec - $39.3 million
2008
Jan - $40.7 million
Feb - $88.8 million
Mar - $84.3 million

Again, I post the numbers only to show an increase in activity during the last couple of months. This in no way indicates where we are on the curve.

I apologize that the numbers aren't side by side. I tried, but it screwed up and combined them.

Edited

SHELLY avatar
SoWal Insider
#119
Re: The bottom has arrived

a little insider data for you non-Realtors. In all of South Walton, including Miramar Bch, the pending sales for the last three months are as follows, for Residential Homes, Townhomes, and Condos, combined. Keep in mind that pending sales are simply listings which are under sales contracts. That doesn't necessarily mean that they will close. They may not. The only reason for me posting this data which is collected from Emerald Coast Assoc. of Realtors, is to show the increase in activity which has been buzzing lately. The data shows :

Pending Sales for Combined Residential Homes in South Walton:

2007
Sep - $48.5 million
Oct - $45.4 million
Nov - $52.6 million
Dec - $39.3 million

2008
Jan - $40.7 million
Feb - $88.8 million
Mar - $84.3 million

So they don't know the "closed" sales (vs pending sales) numbers from these previous months yet?--or haven't any of them closed. :confused:


.
SHELLY avatar
SoWal Insider
#120
Re: The bottom has arrived

Here is my theory on this and why I jumped in at this point.

Most real estate is still way overpriced. Most sellers can not or will not accept where the market is. They continue to drop their prices but not enough to get to where stuff sells. Joe tracks this on his website and I am sure the majority of price decreases are from extremely overpriced to just way overpriced.

I have about 5 buildings that I really like and keep track of prices. Over the last 2+ years a chart of their actual sales prices was constantly going down. But over the last 6 months or so they have or are developing a flat line for actual sale prices. When a seller drops his price down to that line it sells almost immediately. Wether that line is the bottom of the market for that building or a lull in the decline I can't tell you.

As for me, I jumped in because a condo in my favorite building on my favorite floor dropped their asking price to that line. I made them a cash offer for considerably less. I have to tell you I was amazed they took it. But I am thrilled because I got what I wanted. And while prices may be lower in 6 months, the condo I really wanted would most likely be long gone.

JMHO,
Flyguy


FG,

Your purchase makes lots of sense. But do you actually think you'll be kicking yourself in the arse in a couple of years if you don't buy a few more? :blink:


.
.
Smiling JOe avatar
SoWal Expert
#121
Re: The bottom has arrived

Shelly, yes, closed sales are known for Feb and Mar. However, it typically takes about 30 days for most contracts to come to close, so showing the pendings is simply nothing more than a way of showing the increase in contracts being written, and if the Mar pendings do go to close, they would most likely be closing around April. I thought I was clear in my statement regarding my post being nothing more than something showing increases in activity lately. If I was not clear in that, I apologize. I do track closed sales, too.
SHELLY avatar
SoWal Insider
#122
Re: The bottom has arrived

If I was not clear in that, I apologize. I do track closed sales, too.

No, you were clear about the pending. But I was wondering how those "pendings" actually turned into sales--given the tightening credit situation. So what percentage of these pendings are turning into closed sales? (100%? 80%?)



.
Smiling JOe avatar
SoWal Expert
#123
Re: The bottom has arrived

Shelly, I don't think that information of conversions of pendings to closed sales is currently available from ECAR. That sure would give us better data to project future closings, if taken with other knowledge such as that you mention, the tightening credit market, tougher appraisals, etc. I will speak with Geoff at ECAR tomorrow and see if there is a way to make that information available. We are limited by the Solid Earth software, but it may just be that the info is available but not currently set up to access it.
dunelover avatar
Beach Fanatic
#124
Re: The bottom has arrived

My intent was to show the increase in activity during the recent months, rather than comparing quarters. I don't think the contracts written in Feb and Mar were related to Spring Break in any way.
Thanks for the clarification.

Shelly, I don't think that information of conversions of pendings to closed sales is currently available from ECAR. That sure would give us better data to project future closings, if taken with other knowledge such as that you mention, the tightening credit market, tougher appraisals, etc. I will speak with Geoff at ECAR tomorrow and see if there is a way to make that information available. We are limited by the Solid Earth software, but it may just be that the info is available but not currently set up to access it.
SJ--You certainly seem to really stay on top of this market. I am impressed by your willingness to get even more information to help your customers. It seems a potential buyer would be smart to look you up. :clap:
SHELLY avatar
SoWal Insider
#125
Re: The bottom has arrived

Shelly, I don't think that information of conversions of pendings to closed sales is currently available from ECAR. That sure would give us better data to project future closings, if taken with other knowledge such as that you mention, the tightening credit market, tougher appraisals, etc. I will speak with Geoff at ECAR tomorrow and see if there is a way to make that information available. We are limited by the Solid Earth software, but it may just be that the info is available but not currently set up to access it.

So they have the "pendings $" but they don't have the "closings $?" That's really odd :blink:...or maybe they just don't want that stuff known.

If they do, like Oct '07 Pending was $45.5 million...and Oct '07 Closing was $40 million, I can do the percentage math for them. :D

BTW, thanks for the numbers.



.

Edited

Smiling JOe avatar
SoWal Expert
#126
Re: The bottom has arrived

Thank you, dunelover. I come from a background of open sharing of information. By sharing information with other agents (yes, they are my competition, but they are also people with whom I closely work) and customers, we all are more informed, and can make better purchasing decisions, and see possible trends in the market. Remember that statistics are only a bunch of numbers. Understanding how the numbers are compiled and asking questions regarding why sales have a spike or a huge dip, you really don't have a complete grasp of what the stats mean. I encourage questions with all of the stats I give.

Checking your forum account

Please wait while we verify your forum account.