I liked the remoteness, but I can see where it wouldn't be everyone's cuppa tea. I'd move there in a second though.
I'm with you. I could definitely live there. Well, I would probably live in Indian Pass, nearby.
The sand and water not quite the same as SoWal as far as pristine, clear, etc. But, it has its own kind of beauty. Plus, there are few people along the beaches... dogs still allowed, bonfires are fine with no permit required... you can drive along the beach with a permit but there are few people or cars out there. I've seen several golf cart or 4 wheeler type vehicles carting people on the beach. Lots of fishing in the gulf and bay areas.
It seems like a big preserve, still remote with much natural beauty - there are plenty of houses/condos but built respectfully back from the beach, preserving dune lines. St Joseph's State Park at the tip of San Blas is one of our favorite parks in the State of Florida.
Shop at the Piggly Wiggly in Port St Joe on your way in and buy all the food you need. Dining out in Apalachicola and Port St Joe is always fun, if not all that convenient. The restaurants are wonderful. And shopping in Apalach - the BEST!