• Trouble logging in? Send us a message with your username and/or email address for help.
New posts

PearlSB4U

Beach Fanatic
Aug 28, 2010
345
78
The article at the link below argues that U.S. Conservatism has morphed into three fundamentalisms: Biblical, Constitutionalism, and Economic.

Fundamentalists believe in certain eternal Truths that never vary: “the will of God, the principles of the Founding Fathers, the...laws of the free market.” These eternal Truths are codified in the King James Bible, The US Constitution, and the writings of Ayn Rand & Friedrich von Hayek, respectively.

Conservatives/Fundamentalists believe history

“is a story of original perfection, followed by betrayal and restoration. The early Christian church was perfect; it was corrupted and betrayed by medieval Catholicism; and it was restored to its original purity by radical Protestant reformers.

In the same way, the American constitution was not a flawed compromise among rival states and factions, to be improved by later amendment, but a document of superhuman wisdom, created in a kind of secular Pentecost at Philadelphia in the summer of 1787. To believe today’s constitutional fundamentalists, the true constitution was betrayed around 1900 in the name of the "living constitution" by progressives and liberals....

[Modern market fundamentalists ignore]
the long history of tariffs, land grants, military procurement and mixed public-private corporations in the United States, [and] pretend that the U.S. was governed by the laws of the market until Franklin D. Roosevelt’s New Deal replaced capitalism with socialism...

...The rise of triple fundamentalism on the American right creates a crisis of political discourse in the United States...if your sect alone understands the True Religion and the True Constitution and the Laws of the Market, then there is no point in debate. All those who disagree with you are heretics...”

http://www.salon.com/books/history/...ar_room/2011/07/05/lind_three_fundamentalisms
 
Last edited:

30ashopper

SoWal Insider
Apr 30, 2008
6,845
3,471
58
Right here!
The author seems to miss the obvious - social conservatives and progressives have a lot in common as far as the role of government is concerned. They’d both get along just fine if progressives would stop trying to kill religion and social conservatives would stop trying to push it on the masses.

Politics in this country sits between two extremes - conservatism and progressivism, in between those you have middle-of-the-road America - the majority. (So relax, the world is not about to come to an end.) The country flows between the two sides like waves in a basin. I'm happy to be living at a time when the the wave sits center-right, a necessary correction from the days of FDR. (You might not be so happy, tough luck for you, blame your parents.)
 
Last edited:

Andy A

Beach Fanatic
Feb 28, 2007
4,389
1,738
Blue Mountain Beach
Change the last 100 years to only 10.
 
Change the last 100 years to only 10.

I trace the orgins of the problems to the 16th Amendment ( Florida can be proud that it never ratified it), the birth of the Federal Reserve and Prohibition (18th Amendment which unfortunately Florida ratified) among other acts of the socalled progressive era of T. Roosevelt, Taft and Wilson.
However you are correct, the last 10 years have been far worse than the previous 90.
 
Last edited:

Andy A

Beach Fanatic
Feb 28, 2007
4,389
1,738
Blue Mountain Beach
You are also correct. I had not thought of it in that perspective but you are absolutely right.
 

scooterbug44

SoWal Expert
May 8, 2007
16,706
3,339
Sowal
You need a history refresher if you think the last 10 years have been worse than the 90 before.

Great Depression trumps Great Recession, Stock Market Crash beats Stock Market Slump, and Vietnam, Korea and WW2 had 100 times the US deaths of Iraq and Afghanistan.

I will agree that Bush doubling our debt during his terms and Obama adding to it are quite bad, but even combined, they still can't beat Truman and Roosevelt's number if you base it on GDP percentage.
 
New posts


Sign Up for SoWal Newsletter