Everytime we visit the area, my FIL and husband HAVE to get GodFather's pizza. We used to have one in our area that closed many years ago, so they like to relive in the old glory days. All I know is it's by a Dodges Chicken. ;P
Also, it's worthwhile to check out the fishing pier even if you don't fish. At least one day during our stay, the the guys go fishing down there and after a morning of shopping, we'll go visit. I think it's just $1 or $2 to walk out there, but it is pretty neat. Since the water is so clear, so can see straight to the bottom. Jellyfish, sea turtles, dolphins, sting rays. You can see them all!