Back to SoWal Lounge

13,000 protest Governor's plan to change collective bargaining for public employees

scooterbug44 avatar
scooterbug44SoWal Expert
9,806 views
Schools are closed because 40% of the teachers called in sick, the Governor is threatening to call out the National Guard, protesters spent the night sleeping in the Capitol building, the Super Bowl Champs are taking sides, and the police have shut down the streets around the governor's house (in a different city) due to hundreds of protesters.

This is going to be interesting to watch - mass civil disobedience, plus the parallels between this governor and Florida's Scott are interesting. (He turned down high speed rail money, is offering tax breaks to get businesses to relocate, wants to sell off state assets, appointed someone in construction to streamline the DNR, isn't taking a salary etc.)

Thousands descend on Wis. Capitol in protest - Politics - More politics - msnbc.com

MADISON, Wis. ? Thousands of people descended on the Wisconsin state Capitol for a second day of powerful protests Wednesday as key votes approached on Republican Gov. Scott Walker's plan to strip away the collective bargaining rights of public employees.

While other states have proposed bills curtailing labor rights, Wisconsin's measure is the boldest step by a new Republican governor and Legislature to solve budget problems by confronting organized labor. It would end collective bargaining, except over wages less than the Consumer Price Index, for all state, county and local workers except for police, firefighters and the state patrol.

Walker's plan would make workers pay half the costs of their pensions and at least 12.6 percent of their health care premiums. State employees' costs would go up by an average of 8 percent. The changes would save the state $30 million by June 30 and $300 million over the next two years to address a $3.6 billion budget shortfall. Unions could still represent workers, but could not seek pay increases above the Consumer Price Index unless approved by a public referendum. Unions also could not force employees to pay dues and would have to hold annual votes to stay organized. Local police, firefighters and state troopers would retain their collective bargaining rights.

Replies

225
beachFoolBeach Fanatic
#102
So your Oklahoma pension is untouchable, but a government worker in Wisconsin is SOL.

"I was for the pensions before I was against the pension"

Are you channelling John Kerry?
scooterbug44 avatar
scooterbug44SoWal ExpertAuthor
#103
Just curious. Does this kind of rhetoric go for your Dad and Mom as well? I don't know how many times I have to say it. Every bit of our present problems have happened in the last decade and were caused by a myriad of things. Also, please quit twisting what I post to suit your particular spin. I did not say anything about the needy.
It would if they didn't both realize the current system was unsustainable and in need of major change.

Even if we hadn't had the recent Recession and a Republican was elected President in '08, we would still need to be making these cuts and changes. Hell, I knew it was an issue back when I was in grade school.

This problem did not just happen in the last couple of years or the last decade - it just came to a head in that time period and was magnified by the economy. It was decades in the making and the buck kept getting passed - just like Social Security and Medicare on the federal level.

Just a thought from one who has saved, planned and worked hard to put his family on a sound footing during retirement, only it sometimes appears, to have the efforts ruined by those interested in making sure those who have floated through life are guaranteed a comfortable existence in their old age. Bitter at what I see happening? You bet and rightly so!

I didn't say anything about the needy either, I said you were worried about your benefits being taken away and given to lazy people.
Andy A avatar
Andy ABeach Fanatic
#105
Wisconsin Revolts: A Stirring Video Chronicle | The Nation

great video on the Wisconsin protests. Good to see the students standing with their teachers and the firefighters--the 60s live again! :clap:
This is the last I say on this subject. "The 60s live again" says volumes on what has gone wrong in this country. While some of the youth of that era were protesting and blowing up buildings, (so I am told, I wasn't here at the time) other youth were being killed and wounded in a war, which, whether you agreed with it or not, they were asked to fight by their country. They did so valiantly without being able to respond to the protesters. Yeah, all of you who demonstrated in the 60's should be really proud. You won, at the cost of over 58,000 lives and troops being spit on upon their return. IMO, it is a very dark period in our history and there is one thing for which I am really thankful. Those returning from their service in combat areas now are being treated with respect and recognition for what has been asked of them. Maybe those protesters have learned something of value by now.
scooterbug44 avatar
scooterbug44SoWal ExpertAuthor
#106
That is your view - there was a lot more to protests in the 60s than just Vietnam. My parents protested in the 60s, yet have always had a very high regard for members of the armed forces.
Andy A avatar
Andy ABeach Fanatic
#107
That is your view - there was a lot more to protests in the 60s than just Vietnam. My parents protested in the 60s, yet have always had a very high regard for members of the armed forces.
As I said earlier, I spent from 1965 to 1969 out of country, so I have little actual knowlege of protests other than those against Vietnam.
30ashopper avatar
30ashopperSoWal Insider
#108
Columbia University students heckled a war hero during a town-hall meeting on whether ROTC should be allowed back on campus.

"Racist!" some students yelled at Anthony Maschek, a Columbia freshman and former Army staff sergeant awarded the Purple Heart after being shot 11 times in a firefight in northern Iraq in February 2008. Others hissed and booed the veteran.

Wounded Iraq veteran jeered for speaking in Columbia University ROTC debate - NYPOST.com

It still goes on today.
scooterbug44 avatar
scooterbug44SoWal ExpertAuthor
#109
There are always idiots - in the article you posted, other students were criticizing those people because their stupidity was counterproductive and they found the treatment of the vet "abhorrent".

There were people against Columbia having ROTC and their reasons included don't ask, don't tell, high sexual assault numbers among females, amount spent on wars etc.

My college had ROTC and no issues.
Andy A avatar
Andy ABeach Fanatic
#110
Hell, my high school had ROTC and no issues.:lol:
scooterbug44 avatar
scooterbug44SoWal ExpertAuthor
#111
Our high school didn't have ROTC - just military recruiters.
poppyBanned
#112
This is the last I say on this subject. "The 60s live again" says volumes on what has gone wrong in this country. While some of the youth of that era were protesting and blowing up buildings, (so I am told, I wasn't here at the time) other youth were being killed and wounded in a war, which, whether you agreed with it or not, they were asked to fight by their country. They did so valiantly without being able to respond to the protesters. Yeah, all of you who demonstrated in the 60's should be really proud. You won, at the cost of over 58,000 lives and troops being spit on upon their return. IMO, it is a very dark period in our history and there is one thing for which I am really thankful. Those returning from their service in combat areas now are being treated with respect and recognition for what has been asked of them. Maybe those protesters have learned something of value by now.

When I returned from Vietnam in full uniform to LAX I saw no protesters, was not spat upon or shown disrespect in any form. For the next two years I flew around the country in uniform on military standby and still never experienced any disrespect. I believe you are hanging onto a story about a small number of people acting like a-holes not some big movement. Get over it, these types will always be around.
GoodWitch58Beach Fanatic
#113
This is the last I say on this subject. "The 60s live again" says volumes on what has gone wrong in this country. While some of the youth of that era were protesting and blowing up buildings, (so I am told, I wasn't here at the time) other youth were being killed and wounded in a war, which, whether you agreed with it or not, they were asked to fight by their country. They did so valiantly without being able to respond to the protesters. Yeah, all of you who demonstrated in the 60's should be really proud. You won, at the cost of over 58,000 lives and troops being spit on upon their return. IMO, it is a very dark period in our history and there is one thing for which I am really thankful. Those returning from their service in combat areas now are being treated with respect and recognition for what has been asked of them. Maybe those protesters have learned something of value by now.

Andy, while you were serving in Vietnam my husband and I were serving overseas as well...I was both a protester and a supporter of the military. The two are not mutually exclusive...

The protests helped end the war and I am proud to have been a part of that--I only wish we had been able to help stop it before so many of my friends and family died.

I spent long hours in the Navy hospital helping care for wounded military--just off the medivac plane from SE Asia...and most of them would have welcomed a protest to end the hell they had just survived.

Yes, there were some people with their own agendas, there always are...but, I am just as proud of those young people in Wisconsin today(two of them are relatives of friends of mine) as I was of my friends and neighbors of the sixties--they are not what is wrong with our country today-- in fact, they just may help get it back to a rational place.

Edited

Rita avatar
Ritamargarita brocolia
#114
Andy, while you were serving in Vietnam my husband and I were serving overseas as well...I was both a protester and a supporter of the military. The two are not mutually exclusive...

The protests helped end the war and I am proud to have been a part of that--I only wish we had been able to help stop it before so many of my friends and family died.

I spent long hours in the Navy hospital helping care for wounded military--just off the medivac plane from SE Asia...and most of them would have welcomed a protest to end the hell they had just survived.

Yes, there were some people with their own agendas, there always are...but, I am just as proud of those young people in Wisconsin today(two of them are relatives of friends of mine) as I was of my friends and neighbors of the sixties--they are not what is wrong with our country today-- in fact, they just may help get it back to a rational place.
.
...This was my first thought after reading Andy A's post.
Glenda, this is one of the best posts I've read in a while and spot on!


.
GoodWitch58Beach Fanatic
#115
thanks, Rita. I know that I can get blunt at times, but it really irritates me to have anyone believe that their way is the ONLY WAY to view something....and to do it over and over again.

My family has a long history of being in the military and serving honorablly...AND a long history of standing up for what we believe in a peaceful way...which I have always believed is the American way...
Rita avatar
Ritamargarita brocolia
#116
.
This just in. ..:shock:

"The governor's main line is busy, so I'll have to grab an in-person spokesman confirmation or denial in a bit.* Until then: Ian Murphy of the Buffalo Beast claims to have posed as "David Koch" and gotten 20 minutes on the phone with Gov. Scott Walker, goading him to take the hardest possible line against unions. (The Koch brothers got the #2 slot in the Beast's annual "most loathsome Americans" list.)

I think Murphy gets a scoop here when he gets Walker to explain a ruse that could bring the Senate back in session. He's discussing the missing Senate Democrats..........."

Weigel : Did Scott Walker Reveal His Crisis-Ending Ruse to a Prank Caller?


.
Geo avatar
GeoBeach Fanatic
#117
Holy cow- I think this deserves its own thread. I think this is going to be HUGE!
30ashopper avatar
30ashopperSoWal Insider
#118
The minority party in the legislature responded with a collective freak-out. Massive populist protests were held, drawing national press attention. A few signs in the crowd compared the newly elected executive to Hitler. Partisan cable TV opinion anchors doubled their duty, drumming up the crowds and then offering "analysis" on air. The language of apocalypse was invoked, the battle lines were drawn -- and domestic politics started to feel a little like a war.

No, this isn't a recap of Washington 2009 after Barack Obama's election, but Wisconsin 2011 after Gov. Scott Walker's election. And if you were offended by one, but cheering the other, you're part of the problem -- an atmosphere of hyperpartisanship in which extremes on both sides of the political spectrum act like wingnuts crying wolf.

Wisconsin's street theater stalemate obscures real issues - CNN.com
30ashopper avatar
30ashopperSoWal Insider
#119
Democrats are in Illinois, in their third-day of a walkout that began Monday in a protest over a bill targeting labor union talks but which encompasses many more labor and education bills. House Minority Leader B. Patrick Bauer, D-South Bend, said Democrats would not return today, and that it was a ?day to day? discussion about when they would return.

Democrats issued a list of 11 bills they say are concerns, including one which already has passed the legislature and is on its way to Daniels? desk: a fix to the state?s busted unemployment fund. That legislation cuts benefits to the jobless while also raising taxes on businesses.

Bauer said he knows that not all the bills Democrats oppose could be stopped, but said some are essential, including the so-called ?right to work? bill banning unions and companies from negotiating contracts that require non-union members to pay for representation and also the voucher bill which lets tax dollars pay for private school tuition. Bauer also singled out a bill which limits collective bargaining for teachers to wages and wage-related benefits, but not working conditions.

House Speaker Brian Bosma, R-Indianapolis, said Republicans would not negotiate and that the Democrats needed to return from Illinois to do their jobs.

Daniels said the Democrats actions are ?un-democratic? and that they simply are trying to re-fight the November elections, in which voters put Republicans in charge.

?You don?t walk off the job, take your public paycheck with you and bring the whole process to a screeching halt,? Daniels said.

He also clarified his remarks to reporters made Tuesday, in which he had said the activities of the past few days were an acceptable part of the process. Daniels said he was talking about the thousands of labor union members who have come to the Statehouse to protest, and not the Democrats? walkout.

Republicans have killed a controversial labor bill that has sparked a Democrat work-stoppage and large union protests at the Statehouse.

Indiana Senate leader says right-to-work bill is dead | The Indianapolis Star | indystar.com

Another group of spoiled children recently chastised by votes goes stomping off into a corner.

Imagine if this was common practice amoung all law makers.
Rita avatar
Ritamargarita brocolia
#120
.
Not all prominent republicans view these kind of walkouts as childish stompouts:

"Just as they've done in Wisconsin and Indiana, as an Illinois state rep Abe Lincoln once fled the state house -- exiting out a window -- to prevent a vote on a controversial bill. But all week, conservatives -- as well as a few confused pseudo-liberals -- have been advancing the argument that when a minority in a legislature uses parliamentary procedures it's some kind of assault on democracy. There's even an effort underway to recall the 14 Wisconsin senators who left the state last week.

Today, Think Progress reports that not all conservatives have bought into this argument.

Yesterday, Indiana Gov. Mitch Daniels (R) defended his state?s vanished senators, saying their fleeing is ?perfectly legitimate?:

Daniels, a Republican, said earlier Tuesday he supported the Democrats? right to deny Republicans a quorum to do business and the rights of labor unions to protest at the Statehouse.

?The activities of today are perfectly legitimate part of the process,? he said. ?Even the smallest minority, and that?s what we?ve heard from in the last couple days, has every right to express the strength of its views and I salute those who did.?

Today, appearing on conservative radio host Laura Igraham?s show, Ohio Gov. John Kasich (R) ? who has been one of Walker?s most reliable defenders and whom Walker says he talks to ?everyday? ? refused to condmen the senators? actions or Daniels? comments, saying to a displeased Ingraham, ?If you were there, you might end up walking out the chamber too!?......"

ThinkProgress ? GOP Govs. Daniels And Kasich Defend Dem Lawmakers? Walkout As ?Perfectly Legitimate?


.

Checking your forum account

Please wait while we verify your forum account.