No, but here's my problem with the premise. Self employed folks with assets but weak cash flow are numerous especially in a weak economy. Catastrophic coverage is better for these folks than paying a penalty and subsidizing everyone else. To ask young people to pay clearly inafforable rates and then justify it by telling them they'll get a nice refund is pure fantasy for those struggling in the mid/lower tiers of society. On the face of it, this is a dead giveaway to for-profit insurers first, folks with preexisting conditions,and the indigent through Medicaid. It crushes people who are not asking for help. This is the same problem I have with the administration approach to immigration. They aren't addressing the underlying problem of the bum rush at our borders. ACA does not address the underlying problem with healthcare. It's a well intentioned half assed give away to corporations, but does not reign in healthcare costs. That's my whole disappointment with Obama as president. He does not fight for his core beliefs, is weak in leadership, and he takes the path of least resistance on these huge issues.