
I think Paula was the winner tonight LOL! She looked pretty, read her lines well and made it original!
Honestly, Randy has 6 phrases that come out when you pull the string:
Your are in the zone
You can sing the phone book
It was pitchy
That's the bomb
You are in it to win it
It was just ok for me
Simon made the same reference about the Chihuahua and the tiger on Carrie Underwood. Hmm. Does that mean David A will win?
David vs. David in the finale
David Cook for sure. Loved his version of "The First Time..." . Always hated that song by Roberta Flack. LOVED it by him!
David A. did a good job with the B. Joel song. Not so good on his other two.
Syesha...just so so.
IMHO.

DD, I had goosebumps when David Cook sang that song by Roberta Flack!! I could listen to him do that song a million times.
David A murdered Dan Fogleberg. I have that album (yes, the vinyl) downstairs in the basement. I could never bear to give it away or throw it out. I know Dan was turning in his grave tonight.![]()

Yeah, I kinda had that goosebump thing going too--it was that good. Like I said, I was never a fan of the song before, but OMG.
it's on youtube, if you want to hear it again.