There is another thread.
Regardless of your personal feelings about pot smoking and it's legality, Phelps is a role model who did something illegal.
I care less about the fact that a role model did it then the fact that a great athlete is so careless with their body (he has also had past alcohol problems). Swimming is a sport with very low tolerances for error - thousandths of a second are the difference in a gold and silver medal and he's hitting a bong!
you have a point, but really its his choice. good or bad. it belongs only to him.
Most of the swimmers I know (and I've known some of the best) are hard partiers. I don't begrudge a swimmer wishing to partake. Problem for Phelps is he's a public figure who is an icon to many children. Answering a kid's (under 10) questions about Phelps, bongs and weed is really awkward and uncool. He needs to show a little more restraint in his private life so that his dirty laundry doesn't explode on the public scene.
you are right that he should show more restraint. but then again, I say its his choice entirely. if he loses sponsors or whatever, those are the consequences, just like any young person has to face if they make certain choices and get caught. I would say he needs to be more choosey about friends and surroundings. and do whatever the hail he wants to do.
Geo - I think lots of healthy discussion is going on because of Phelps (this thread is an example), even if he did apologize. he was just doing what he had to do by publicly apologozing - its kind of good common courtesy. Surely he meant, "I'm sorry for getting caught on camera".

actually, I'm sure he is highly embarrassed and feeling like an dumbarse right about now for the whole thing. If and when he tokes again, he'll be sure to be in a very private setting. Geo - you make total sense. I especially agree with your statement that I just wish i did not have to know - what a shame! it is just not anyone's business.
lots more people smoke pot, from my old aunt to someone's grandma I won't mention, leaders around the world, losers, champions, sick people in pain, and every kind of person in between, including athletes. someday it will have to be legalized. my only concern now and in the future is educating children about its harmful effects and keeping it out of their hands, as much as alcohol, pills and any drug.