After much searching of the Caribbean, I'm leaning towards Puerto Rico or Jamaica. So many islands take 10-14 hours with flights, layovers, seaplanes and ferry rides and I don't want to lose 2 days of vacation to travel. Jamaica and Puerto Rico have nonstop flights out of Dallas and only take about 4.5 hours in the air-much more appealing. If I'm going to travel for 10 hours or more, I'd want to go to Europe again! Several have recommended Kauai but that time change kills me on the return.