As a fairly new poster here, but a long time (20+years) resident, I have spent most of today reading this thread and would like to share a few things that I observed over time in SOWAL. When I first moved here there were no arguments about public/private beach. Most people here used a bit south of the vegetation line, or where the seaweed became dry as the MHTL. The tide had to have been that high at some point very recently for the seaweed to have been deposited there, right? But I noticed an alarming trend about 12-15 years ago when reading the real estate ads I saw realtors, many new to this area, putting the words "private beach" in ads for property here. I had a feeling that it would eventually come to this with people from different areas moving in from places that had very DEFINATE property lines and no idea of how Mother Nature works on the beach. I just shook my head when the stink was raised about renourishment of "private beach" as I watched the next hurricane build the beach right back up to near the levels it was originally. Now I think we should adopt the same type of thing that South Carolina (I think) has..you can build your house as far on the beach as you like, but if a storm takes it you can NOT rebuild. Just imagine how many of these multi-million dollar homes would have never been built if the owners had been told THAT. As far as the Retreat thinking they are "special" with their "private beach" I would like to share the fact that the Retreat was hand picked by private plane by the executives of ..(are you ready?..) ST. JOE and their investors for their PERSONAL houses when the area was being prepared to be sold for residential housing. Shouldnt be any questions as to why the favoritism is being shown by any of our officials. I also agree that if we as citizens done stand up to this right now the $$ will win.